User Panel
[#2]
Quoted:
Here's my two cents. Any modern combatant who would carry an ak into combat over an ar is retarded. This conclusion could be made on the controls alone. Horrible safety, optic mounting, magazine loading, charging handle, ect The internals on a real AKM are completely asinine. The AR is much easier to fully break down. Please do not argue this unless you have assembled a real AKM fire control group. With that all said I do like the AK for what it is. I do own one and enjoy shooting it. In true arfcom fashion. Get both! View Quote Safety. Eh, sure. Optics mount? No. Plenty of great solutions available now. Same with furniture and everything else for the AK. It's not five years ago. Internals asinine? No. They are fine. |
|
[#3]
Quoted:
Problem? While we are at it the sights and trigger are horrible too. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Here's my two cents. Any modern combatant who would carry an ak into combat over an ar is retarded. This conclusion could be made on the controls alone. Horrible safety, optic mounting, magazine loading, charging handle, ect The internals on a real AKM are completely asinine. The AR is much easier to fully break down. Please do not argue this unless you have assembled a real AKM fire control group. With that all said I do like the AK for what it is. I do own one and enjoy shooting it. In true arfcom fashion. Get both! What in the ever loving fuck!? wow Problem? While we are at it the sights and trigger are horrible too. Lol. Sights are fine for irons. Tapco G2 and ATK are great triggers. |
|
[#4]
Both have been going strong all over the world for the better part of a century now. Both are gtg if its not a piece of shit mechanically speaking.
|
|
[#5]
I have 3 top of the trashcan izhmash russian aks.
They're fun, but AR'S are "better". More accuratr, better bullets, better ergos, better accessories. Reliability is a wash at best (for the ak) I've had significantly fewer malfunctons in the last few thousand rounds thru AR than AK, and I consider maintaining my ar to be squirting some clp in the dust cover once a month. I wouldnt want to get shot at by either. ETA - I am retarded for stepping into this thread. Some super derp here. |
|
[#6]
Quoted:
Safety. Eh, sure. Optics mount? No. Plenty of great solutions available now. Same with furniture and everything else for the AK. It's not five years ago. Internals asinine? No. They are fine. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Here's my two cents. Any modern combatant who would carry an ak into combat over an ar is retarded. This conclusion could be made on the controls alone. Horrible safety, optic mounting, magazine loading, charging handle, ect The internals on a real AKM are completely asinine. The AR is much easier to fully break down. Please do not argue this unless you have assembled a real AKM fire control group. With that all said I do like the AK for what it is. I do own one and enjoy shooting it. In true arfcom fashion. Get both! Safety. Eh, sure. Optics mount? No. Plenty of great solutions available now. Same with furniture and everything else for the AK. It's not five years ago. Internals asinine? No. They are fine. So you have experience with an actual AKM internals? How do I mount a scope? The non standardarized cantilever mount? Or maybe I mount it to something that's not an afixed position in relashionship to the barrel. |
|
[#7]
Quoted:
Lol. Sights are fine for irons. Tapco G2 and ATK are great triggers. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Here's my two cents. Any modern combatant who would carry an ak into combat over an ar is retarded. This conclusion could be made on the controls alone. Horrible safety, optic mounting, magazine loading, charging handle, ect The internals on a real AKM are completely asinine. The AR is much easier to fully break down. Please do not argue this unless you have assembled a real AKM fire control group. With that all said I do like the AK for what it is. I do own one and enjoy shooting it. In true arfcom fashion. Get both! What in the ever loving fuck!? wow Problem? While we are at it the sights and trigger are horrible too. Lol. Sights are fine for irons. Tapco G2 and ATK are great triggers. What sights are you comparing it to? A nerf gun? Way to mention two after market triggers. Since we are comparing aftermarkets want to put them up against a SSA-E trigger? |
|
[#8]
Quoted:
What sights are you comparing it to? A nerf gun? Way to mention two after market triggers. Since we are comparing aftermarkets want to put them up against a SSA-E trigger? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Here's my two cents. Any modern combatant who would carry an ak into combat over an ar is retarded. This conclusion could be made on the controls alone. Horrible safety, optic mounting, magazine loading, charging handle, ect The internals on a real AKM are completely asinine. The AR is much easier to fully break down. Please do not argue this unless you have assembled a real AKM fire control group. With that all said I do like the AK for what it is. I do own one and enjoy shooting it. In true arfcom fashion. Get both! What in the ever loving fuck!? wow Problem? While we are at it the sights and trigger are horrible too. Lol. Sights are fine for irons. Tapco G2 and ATK are great triggers. What sights are you comparing it to? A nerf gun? Way to mention two after market triggers. Since we are comparing aftermarkets want to put them up against a SSA-E trigger? The Tapco G2 trigger is the most common trigger found in any AK you will buy these day. It is basically the standard. Due to compliance issues pretty much every AK imported into the US will have an "aftermarket" trigger. ETA: And as far as the AKT goes, it is a $50 trigger. |
|
[#9]
Quoted:
The Tapco G2 trigger is the most common trigger found in any AK you will buy these day. It is basically the standard. Due to compliance issues pretty much every AK imported into the US will have an "aftermarket" trigger. ETA: And as far as the AKT goes, it is a $50 trigger. View Quote Ok understandable. Does not negate the other issues though. Now don't take it wrong guys. I do like the AK I have. Just no comparison is usability between the two. |
|
[#10]
Quoted:
Ok understandable. Does not negate the other issues though. Now don't take it wrong guys. I do like the AK I have. Just no comparison is usability between the two. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The Tapco G2 trigger is the most common trigger found in any AK you will buy these day. It is basically the standard. Due to compliance issues pretty much every AK imported into the US will have an "aftermarket" trigger. ETA: And as far as the AKT goes, it is a $50 trigger. Ok understandable. Does not negate the other issues though. Now don't take it wrong guys. I do like the AK I have. Just no comparison is usability between the two. Here is where I get stumped Usability is dependent on the usage, the user, and the user's own familiarity with weapon systems. An AR in the hands of a strict AK user would feel alien, and vice versa. Not sparking an argument, I simply disagree with saying the "usability" is so strongly one sided. |
|
[#11]
Quoted:
Ok understandable. Does not negate the other issues though. Now don't take it wrong guys. I do like the AK I have. Just no comparison is usability between the two. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The Tapco G2 trigger is the most common trigger found in any AK you will buy these day. It is basically the standard. Due to compliance issues pretty much every AK imported into the US will have an "aftermarket" trigger. ETA: And as far as the AKT goes, it is a $50 trigger. Ok understandable. Does not negate the other issues though. Now don't take it wrong guys. I do like the AK I have. Just no comparison is usability between the two. Well that's your opinion and I think it's wrong. Just you think mine is. :) One day, not to long ago, my wife has her cousin over. Both not gun people. They like guns but never Handled them. So as an experiment I pulled out a Magpul AR, a normal wood AK, and a Magoul AK. I first gave them the AR and the plain AK. Obviously they preferred the AR ergonomics. As most would expect. Then I gave them the Magpul AK. Zhukov series. One said she thought both were the same and one thought the AK was better. Remember, this is apples to apples as far as what you can buy already done. Both guns are offered from reputable companies with Magpul furniture. I make it a point to do this test with all the people I can. The results are almost always the same. And there are more options than just the MOE and Zhuckov furniture. So to say the AR ergos are better is not being accurate either unintentionally or intentionally. Obviously it'll vary from person to person, but to proclaim the AR the ultimate winner isn't accurate anymore. And there are plenty of good mounting solutions from the Ultimak to MI or RS side rail mounts that result in some very accurate AK's. But these are opinions and it seems we are unlikely to change each other's. |
|
[#12]
Quoted:
Well that's your opinion and I think it's wrong. Just you think mine is. :) One day, not to long ago, my wife has her cousin over. Both not gun people. They like guns but never Handled them. So as an experiment I pulled out a Magpul AR, a normal wood AK, and a Magoul AK. I first gave them the AR and the plain AK. Obviously they preferred the AR ergonomics. As most would expect. Then I gave them the Magpul AK. Zhukov series. One said she thought both were the same and one thought the AK was better. Remember, this is apples to apples as far as what you can buy already done. Both guns are offered from reputable companies with Magpul furniture. I make it a point to do this test with all the people I can. The results are almost always the same. And there are more options than just the MOE and Zhuckov furniture. So to say the AR ergos are better is not being accurate either unintentionally or intentionally. Obviously it'll vary from person to person, but to proclaim the AR the ultimate winner isn't accurate anymore. And there are plenty of good mounting solutions from the Ultimak to MI or RS side rail mounts that result in some very accurate AK's. But these are opinions and it seems we are unlikely to change each other's. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
The Tapco G2 trigger is the most common trigger found in any AK you will buy these day. It is basically the standard. Due to compliance issues pretty much every AK imported into the US will have an "aftermarket" trigger. ETA: And as far as the AKT goes, it is a $50 trigger. Ok understandable. Does not negate the other issues though. Now don't take it wrong guys. I do like the AK I have. Just no comparison is usability between the two. Well that's your opinion and I think it's wrong. Just you think mine is. :) One day, not to long ago, my wife has her cousin over. Both not gun people. They like guns but never Handled them. So as an experiment I pulled out a Magpul AR, a normal wood AK, and a Magoul AK. I first gave them the AR and the plain AK. Obviously they preferred the AR ergonomics. As most would expect. Then I gave them the Magpul AK. Zhukov series. One said she thought both were the same and one thought the AK was better. Remember, this is apples to apples as far as what you can buy already done. Both guns are offered from reputable companies with Magpul furniture. I make it a point to do this test with all the people I can. The results are almost always the same. And there are more options than just the MOE and Zhuckov furniture. So to say the AR ergos are better is not being accurate either unintentionally or intentionally. Obviously it'll vary from person to person, but to proclaim the AR the ultimate winner isn't accurate anymore. And there are plenty of good mounting solutions from the Ultimak to MI or RS side rail mounts that result in some very accurate AK's. But these are opinions and it seems we are unlikely to change each other's. That just shows their ignorance in firearms Also you can't just handle a firearm once or twice and know what you like or don't. I have been into the shooting sport for over 15 years and sometimes it still takes me some time to determine what I like and dislike. |
|
[#13]
Quoted:
They both have their strengths and weaknesses. Just get both. Variety is fun. View Quote Every post after this one has left me weeping for humanity. I know arfcom is a "discussion" forum, but trading dubious opinions masquerading as facts in an attempt to one up each other isn't "discussion" and only serves to highlight the various posters' ignorance. Reading this thread leads me irresistibly to the old chestnut that it's better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt. |
|
[#14]
Quoted:
Every post after this one has left me weeping for humanity. I know arfcom is a "discussion" forum, but trading dubious opinions masquerading as facts in an attempt to one up each other isn't "discussion" and only serves to highlight the various posters' ignorance. Reading this thread leads me irresistibly to the old chestnut that it's better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
They both have their strengths and weaknesses. Just get both. Variety is fun. Every post after this one has left me weeping for humanity. I know arfcom is a "discussion" forum, but trading dubious opinions masquerading as facts in an attempt to one up each other isn't "discussion" and only serves to highlight the various posters' ignorance. Reading this thread leads me irresistibly to the old chestnut that it's better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt. I see you follow your own advice. I find opinionated discussion enjoyable. Nice to see other peoples side of things. Don't be such a party pooper |
|
[#15]
Quoted:
That just shows Thier ignorance in firearms View Quote I'm not sure how you reached that conclusion. I'm sure you know yourself and that's the case with you but some people can immediately tell what feels good or bad to them. I had a Glock 19 I liked. One day I picked up a M&P and instantly knew I had to have it. It felt better than the Glock, to me, and in turn I shoot better with it. And we have to be specific. In the case of my wife and cousin, shooting the gun would introduce recoil into the equation and cloud my experiment which was purely ergonomics. But again, it's different from person to person anyway so it's hard to quantify. I actually know people who swear they think a regular wood AK has better ergo's than an AR. I call nonsense but they don't waiver. So I think this is just fun internet banter more than anything. No sense in getting worked up over it. For instance, while it seems I'm espousing the virtues of the AK, my current PC SHTF load out us setup for the AR due to my assumption there will be more ammo, mags, and parts laying around. |
|
[#16]
Quoted:
I see you follow your own advice. I find opinionated discussion enjoyable. Nice to see other peoples side of things. Don't be such a party pooper View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
They both have their strengths and weaknesses. Just get both. Variety is fun. Every post after this one has left me weeping for humanity. I know arfcom is a "discussion" forum, but trading dubious opinions masquerading as facts in an attempt to one up each other isn't "discussion" and only serves to highlight the various posters' ignorance. Reading this thread leads me irresistibly to the old chestnut that it's better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt. I see you follow your own advice. I find opinionated discussion enjoyable. Nice to see other peoples side of things. Don't be such a party pooper It's my party, I can poop if I want to. |
|
[#17]
ARs are definitely trash My first AR, piece of garbage Bushmaster 20" never malfunctioned. Second AR, refuse, Double Star build, never malfunctioned, so I Ares Pistoned it, still wouldn't fail. Had problems with 2 Norinco 556 rifles, firing pin hole in bolt would cut a disk out of primers, and after a few rounds would jam fp in bolt. Chamfering the fp hole fixed that. Every 7.62 × 39 AK I've fired has been 100%, even the ones I built with screws. Hell even the screwy home built PSL has been 100% and in slow motion too.
What is wrong with you people If it doesn't work right, make it work right and stop complaining like little girls If it looks cool buy it. |
|
[#18]
|
|
[#19]
I've shot many AR and AK type rifles and have a preference for the AR platform but both rifles do what they were designed for. . The AR ammunition is far lighter to carry more of, the ergonomics are superior, the sighting system is better and so is accuracy BUT I once shot one of the original Bulgarian made Arsenal AKs and it was very accurate. The trouble is that too many cheap low quality AK's are being produced these days. The Century AK's in particular are light duty, very inaccurate and made of soft steel Repetitive rapid fire can and will melt a Century soft steel barrel. Checkout You Tube. The inter ordnance rifles are not much better. Where the AK rifle really stands out is in its ability to work in dirty conditions but if you get an AK that shoots pie plate groups or bigger) it ruins the operating characteristics.. Point is that there are quality AR's and quality AK's If you go cheap you will get poor performance. While the days of the $279.00 Chinese made Norico AK's are gone, and the price of that rifle is now close to what an AR rifle costs, if you spend $500-$700 on an AK insist on quality, a forged receiver and good accuracy.
|
|
[#20]
|
|
[#21]
|
|
[#22]
Quoted:
I've shot many AR and AK type rifles and have a preference for the AR platform but both rifles do what they were designed for. . The AR ammunition is far lighter to carry more of, the ergonomics are superior, the sighting system is better and so is accuracy BUT I once shot one of the original Bulgarian made Arsenal AKs and it was very accurate. The trouble is that too many cheap low quality AK's are being produced these days. The Century AK's in particular are light duty, very inaccurate and made of soft steel Repetitive rapid fire can and will melt a Century soft steel barrel. Checkout You Tube. The inter ordnance rifles are not much better. Where the AK rifle really stands out is in its ability to work in dirty conditions but if you get an AK that shoots pie plate groups or bigger) it ruins the operating characteristics.. Point is that there are quality AR's and quality AK's If you go cheap you will get poor performance. While the days of the $279.00 Chinese made Norico AK's are gone, and the price of that rifle is now close to what an AR rifle costs, if you spend $500-$700 on an AK insist on quality, a forged receiver and good accuracy. View Quote Uh, what? |
|
[#24]
|
|
[#25]
Quoted: For the same reason the Kardashians are still on TV: stupidity sells. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: How is this thread still going? For the same reason the Kardashians are still on TV: stupidity sells. No COC violations I have noticed, so it's running. Couple of mild warnings was all this thread needed. I am surprised and happy at the same time. |
|
[#26]
Or you could just build an AR in 7.62X39 and have the best of both worlds.
It about all I shoot any more. With an AR in 7.62X39 you have Ease of mounting optics, good iron sights, accurate with steel case(twice as accurate as my AK's) Ease of trigger change, ease of replacing parts.... The list is long |
|
[#27]
Quoted:
Or you could just build an AR in 7.62X39 and have the best of both worlds. It about all I shoot any more. With an AR in 7.62X39 you have Ease of mounting optics, good iron sights, accurate with steel case(twice as accurate as my AK's) Ease of trigger change, ease of replacing parts.... The list is long View Quote What kind of volume of fire are you putting through this? I've always worried about how thin the metal was at the lugs on the bolt. Any issues with that? And what magazines are you using? That has always been my other big concern about an AR in 7.62x39. |
|
[#29]
Quoted:
This will go well. ETA: I love the historical significance of the AK pattern rifles, and they are a blast to shoot. I also think that no collection is complete without at least one. With that being said, I do have a preference for the AR15 platform. View Quote Well put. That also expresses my feelings on the matter. |
|
[#30]
Quoted:
Or you could just build an AR in 7.62X39 and have the best of both worlds. It about all I shoot any more. With an AR in 7.62X39 you have Ease of mounting optics, good iron sights, accurate with steel case(twice as accurate as my AK's) Ease of trigger change, ease of replacing parts.... The list is long View Quote Problem with that is you still have all the "issues" you get with a DI gun unless you go piston. You also have the issues about it being picky about mags and maybe even ammo..but I think a lot of that has been resolved. The beauty of an AK is in its simplicity...you can feed them a steady diet of the crappiest surplus ammo you can find, not clean it for hundreds if not thousands or rounds, and generally beat the shit out of it and it will just smile and keep on running. Also there are accurate AKs out there...will one ever be as accurate as a good AR? probably not..but good enough for 90 percent of the people out there...yes. Keep in mind Im a AR guy...I wanted a X39 AR..but the cost to do it right and the finicky nature of them..Im just going to get an AK...its much easier... How much do you have in your builds if you dont mind saying? Because even after having said all that I still haven't completely given up on the x39 AR idea |
|
[#31]
Having gotten into 5.56 AKs recently I'd have to say that the lion's share of accuracy differences are ammo related. In other words, 223/5.56 ammo is way more accurate than 5.45x39 or 7.62x39. ARs are still more accurate but when ammo is similar quality that difference is less than half. So perception is largely based on AR with good ammo vs. AK with junk ammo.
|
|
[#32]
I have always found the AK system to be more the adequate for hitting a man size target.
|
|
[#33]
A carbine type rifle is meant to dominate out to around 200-250M. A decent AK with a switched-on shooter will do that no problem.
|
|
[#35]
How is your di gas system with dirty Russian steel cased ammo? I had a 1600 round run of 55 grain wolf non polymer coated it wasn't accurate like my m193 federal milspec ammo but it went bang in my bushmast m4. Just dirtier than a whore with 100 tricks and no rabbits with fruity cereal, and no bath for a week. lol Ilike the idea of a bastard ar47
<removed> this is a technical forum. dryflash3 |
|
[#36]
Quoted: How is your di gas system with dirty Russian steel cased ammo? I had a 1600 round run of 55 grain wolf non polymer coated it wasn't accurate like my m193 federal milspec ammo but it went bang in my bushmast m4. Just dirtier than a whore with 100 tricks and no rabbits with fruity cereal, and no bath for a week. lol Ilike the idea of a bastard ar47 View Quote I have two x39 ARs and love them dearly. Both are very reliable and will run any ammo I feed them. That said, after a 500 round afternoon with some Wolf, it looks like someone with explosive diarrhea took a dump on my bolt carrier. The term dirty doesn't even begin to cover it. Cleans up easily enough though. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.