|
|
Posted: 4/3/2012 12:06:24 PM
Originally Posted By Gregory_K:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Superlube synthetic grease. Where do people buy this stuff? Lowes or homedepot usally. link Very convenient. Thanks. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/3/2012 4:39:39 PM
[Last Edit: 4/3/2012 4:50:19 PM by Gamma762]
Originally Posted By Gregory_K:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Superlube synthetic grease. Where do people buy this stuff? Lowes or homedepot usally. link I usually just order it direct anymore, but there it is in the above link. Many ( ) years ago I found it at Radio Shack, sold with RS branding in silver color tubes then later in white color tubes like in the above link. RS also carried the precision oiler pens which were the bomb for lubing pistols and such.
The grease today seems a lot thicker than back in the Radio Shack days. The old product was almost clear in color and had a consistency that seemed barely non-liquid. I liked the old stuff better. I talked to someone at the manufacturer but they weren't really interested in discussing the situation, but claimed that the product today was equivalent. The oil they sell is a nice product also here, and you can mix the oil and grease to get any desired consistency. I also use a lot of the aerosol grease mostly for non-firearms maintenance like lubing garage doors, farm equipment, squeaky door hinges, stuff like that. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/3/2012 6:52:25 PM
[Last Edit: 4/3/2012 9:01:23 PM by Blankwaffe98]
Ive used the SuperLube on my TC's before as it was sold as a TC breech Plug grease,and it works extremely well in that application.
That said a few years ago on the 1911forum.com one of the forum members had issues with the SuperLube grease turning gummy and corrosion in the gun when it came in contact with Break Free CLP during storage. http://forums.1911forum.com/showthread.php?t=65119&highlight=Super+Lube+compatibility Always wondered about that as it was the only comment Ive seen in SuperLube incompatibility. Anyone here currently seen any incompatibility issues with SuperLube Grease and CLP,or any other combination? |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/3/2012 7:18:49 PM
Originally Posted By Blankwaffe98:
Ive used the SuperLube on my TC's before as it was sold as a TC breech Plug grease,and it works extremely well in that application. That said a few years ago on the 1911forum.com one of the forum members had issues with the SuperLube grease turning gummy and corrosion in the gun when it came in contact with Break Free CLP during storage. http://forums.1911forum.com/showthread.php?t=65119&highlight=Super+Lube+compatibility Always wondered about that as it was the only comment Ive seen in SuperLube incompatibility. Anyone here currently seen any incompatibility issues with SuperLube Grease and CLP,or any other combination? I've said it before, and I'll say it again ... Yet another reason to avoid using BF CLP. Just sayin' ... |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/4/2012 4:16:04 PM
Originally Posted By Altair:
Originally Posted By JRBL1A1:
Grease??? GREASE??? Evidently you have not heard about CLP. Ask any combat vet that spent time in Iraq and/or Afghanistan about which grease they used. Grease catches and hold on to grit, grime, sand, etc. You don't want that. Oil allows all that to be flushed out. Get some CLP (drip bottle), and lean to use it for everything. I gave up on CLP long ago as a lube. I doesn't clean or lubricate worth a damn, though it does protect well. I use it to condition metal, particularly on the exterior of a weapon or for long term storage, but it burns off way to fast in the action of an AR. I work with several combat vets that feel the same way I do. While grease may not be a great product to use in Iraq or Afghanistan, I don't live or work in a desert. Interesting. I've spoken with multiple vets on lubing the M16/M4 and 2 vets in particular said never would they use grease for the reasons I mentioned above: it holds in the sand/grit/grime/etc. CLP will let it cycle on out. Both said that running the M4 as wet as can be was the key to keeping it running once it gets covered in grit. I've had great luck with CLP doing exactly as it was designed and I think it cleans and lubes rather well. the secret is to use CLP and only CLP. Do not combine it with anything else. I'd rather carry a small 2-4 oz bottle of CLP in my pocket for quick spot clean and lube jobs than try and rely on grease. As usual there is more than 1 way to butcher a cow, but it does help to have a sharp knife. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/4/2012 5:11:51 PM
Originally Posted By Blankwaffe98:
Ive used the SuperLube on my TC's before as it was sold as a TC breech Plug grease,and it works extremely well in that application. That said a few years ago on the 1911forum.com one of the forum members had issues with the SuperLube grease turning gummy and corrosion in the gun when it came in contact with Break Free CLP during storage. http://forums.1911forum.com/showthread.php?t=65119&highlight=Super+Lube+compatibility Always wondered about that as it was the only comment Ive seen in SuperLube incompatibility. Anyone here currently seen any incompatibility issues with SuperLube Grease and CLP,or any other combination? I haven't had a problem with it. Both superlube and break free are PAO base oils. I've mixed them intentionally before and didn't seem to have any adverse effects. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/4/2012 9:08:40 PM
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Originally Posted By Blankwaffe98:
Ive used the SuperLube on my TC's before as it was sold as a TC breech Plug grease,and it works extremely well in that application. That said a few years ago on the 1911forum.com one of the forum members had issues with the SuperLube grease turning gummy and corrosion in the gun when it came in contact with Break Free CLP during storage. http://forums.1911forum.com/showthread.php?t=65119&highlight=Super+Lube+compatibility Always wondered about that as it was the only comment Ive seen in SuperLube incompatibility. Anyone here currently seen any incompatibility issues with SuperLube Grease and CLP,or any other combination? I haven't had a problem with it. Both superlube and break free are PAO base oils. I've mixed them intentionally before and didn't seem to have any adverse effects. Thanks Gamma. Good feedback and what I was looking for.Yeah I thought it was an unusual situation at the time the thread I linked was running.And like I said,its the only comment Ive seen in regards to SuperLube incompatibility,including on the muzzleloading forums.I used the SuperLube on a few inline breech plugs for a couple seasons and saw no issues with the grease being used in/around Ballistol or Break Free CLP.But that thread always stuck in my mind. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/5/2012 9:12:36 AM
Originally Posted By JRBL1A1:
Originally Posted By Altair:
Originally Posted By JRBL1A1:
Grease??? GREASE??? Evidently you have not heard about CLP. Ask any combat vet that spent time in Iraq and/or Afghanistan about which grease they used. Grease catches and hold on to grit, grime, sand, etc. You don't want that. Oil allows all that to be flushed out. Get some CLP (drip bottle), and lean to use it for everything. I gave up on CLP long ago as a lube. I doesn't clean or lubricate worth a damn, though it does protect well. I use it to condition metal, particularly on the exterior of a weapon or for long term storage, but it burns off way to fast in the action of an AR. I work with several combat vets that feel the same way I do. While grease may not be a great product to use in Iraq or Afghanistan, I don't live or work in a desert. Interesting. I've spoken with multiple vets on lubing the M16/M4 and 2 vets in particular said never would they use grease for the reasons I mentioned above: it holds in the sand/grit/grime/etc. CLP will let it cycle on out. Both said that running the M4 as wet as can be was the key to keeping it running once it gets covered in grit. I've had great luck with CLP doing exactly as it was designed and I think it cleans and lubes rather well. the secret is to use CLP and only CLP. Do not combine it with anything else. I'd rather carry a small 2-4 oz bottle of CLP in my pocket for quick spot clean and lube jobs than try and rely on grease. As usual there is more than 1 way to butcher a cow, but it does help to have a sharp knife. As I've mentioned earlier in this thread, my interest in grease isn't just for use on an AR. I do use grease when lubing my AR's, but it is not my primary lubricant. It is only used on a few select high wear areas. As for CLP, I've found that if I clean with CLP and then go back and use an actual solvent, there is quite a bit more gunk that the CLP just doesn't get. CLP requires far more time and effort to clean with. It is better than nothing, but not my first choice. As a lube, it just doesn't stick around in an AR. If you run a rifle with CLP on the BCG and then run one with Lucas or Slip 2000 or Mobil 1 or other quality oil you will see pretty quickly that the CLP lubed gun dries out very quickly. I recently ran a side by side test between two M16's using Lucas Gun Oil and another lube (Super Quick Clean Guns) and after 600 rounds, most on full auto, the BCG using Lucas was still wet. That just won't be true with CLP. The other thread is here. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/7/2012 8:01:12 AM
I've been following this thread from post #1; I've read, reread it and read it again. This is probably one of the most informative threads I've read in the M&C forum.
I can really see the advantage of using grease on an AR, especially the example used by the OP and his carbine riding around in the trunk for a couple months. Grease will stay put, oil will not. This is the info. I was looking for. I get tired of lubing my ARs, storing them vertically and then coming back in a day or two and the oil that was on the BCG is now all over the buffer. I'm like the OP, I want to be able to pull it from the safe, put it into use and KNOW it is still lubed and will run like I need it to. Most of it makes sense, but one post in particular leads me to a question. Another poster stated he uses Mobil 1 synthetic grease for his AR, IIRC. I use AMSOIL synthetic grease around the house. I have seen this grease leak out of a grease gun like water on a hot day. Would it still be advisable to use this on an AR? It seems to me if it will get runny like this on a hot day, it won't stay put on the AR once it gets hot. Am I making sense or am I way off base? |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/8/2012 1:06:26 AM
[Last Edit: 4/8/2012 1:16:22 AM by Dee_NY]
Originally Posted By Saber329:
I've been following this thread from post #1; I've read, reread it and read it again. This is probably one of the most informative threads I've read in the M&C forum. +1, in fact I was discussing this very topic with a family member just last weekend when he pulled out and gave me a big can of grease that he has had since the late 70’s when he was still in the military. I haven't had a chance to research or even try it yet, it’s a big OD color can with yellow marking on it that says: G-403 - GAA Grease, Automotive & Artillery. MIL-G-10924C, 9150-190-0905 SW G & O Wichita, KS. BATCH 78 - DSA600-72-C-1755, QUAL: M-7627......5 U.S. LB. Told me they use to put this stuff on their M16's and on the magazine springs as well. Anyone here ever use or even heard of this stuff? I myself have never used grease before, been using something called EEZOX Synthetic Gun Care for the past 6-10 years now and have never had a problem. However after reading through this thread I definitely plan on picking up and trying out some of the above mentioned products such as the supper lube and TW25b. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/11/2012 12:13:03 PM
I use the Rig, but I think it is all going to come down to personal preference and performance, use what works best for you and your weapon.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/15/2012 11:37:13 PM
Originally Posted By Saber329:
I can really see the advantage of using grease on an AR, especially the example used by the OP and his carbine riding around in the trunk for a couple months. Grease will stay put, oil will not. This is the info. I was looking for. I get tired of lubing my ARs, storing them vertically and then coming back in a day or two and the oil that was on the BCG is now all over the buffer. I'm like the OP, I want to be able to pull it from the safe, put it into use and KNOW it is still lubed and will run like I need it to. Hence, one of the benefits of using oil, at least in military applications. Once the rifle gets dirty, the oil (in this case CLP) will cycle out of the weapon and take with it all the grit, grime, sand, and other substances in which we do not want within the internals. Grease will keep it in, allow it to cake up, and facilitate weapon malfunctions. If all the shooter is going to be doing is sitting on a bench and/or otherwise shooting in a very clean and controlled environment that isn't in the dead of winter, then sure grease it up all ya want. In short, target shooter = grease up all ya want. Military/combat = stick with CLP. YMMV, and there is an obvious difference of opinion, but I can't fathom using 2-3 different kinds of lube on my rifle when 1 will do it all and do it all very well. If I'm ever in a situation where I've fired 600 rounds in the middle of a desert and my rifle "runs dry", the small bottle of CLP will be handy and in less than 30 seconds later I will be up and running for another 600 rounds. I carry with me a small bottle of CLP where ever the rifle goes, but I get that from carrying my rifle in a squad car in my former days of being a deputy sheriff. Enough Iraq/Afgan vets have mentioned "keeping it wet" enough times that it still makes sense to me to keep doing it. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/16/2012 9:24:46 AM
[Last Edit: 4/16/2012 9:25:44 AM by Altair]
Originally Posted By JRBL1A1:
Originally Posted By Saber329:
I can really see the advantage of using grease on an AR, especially the example used by the OP and his carbine riding around in the trunk for a couple months. Grease will stay put, oil will not. This is the info. I was looking for. I get tired of lubing my ARs, storing them vertically and then coming back in a day or two and the oil that was on the BCG is now all over the buffer. I'm like the OP, I want to be able to pull it from the safe, put it into use and KNOW it is still lubed and will run like I need it to. Hence, one of the benefits of using oil, at least in military applications. Once the rifle gets dirty, the oil (in this case CLP) will cycle out of the weapon and take with it all the grit, grime, sand, and other substances in which we do not want within the internals. Grease will keep it in, allow it to cake up, and facilitate weapon malfunctions. If all the shooter is going to be doing is sitting on a bench and/or otherwise shooting in a very clean and controlled environment that isn't in the dead of winter, then sure grease it up all ya want. In short, target shooter = grease up all ya want. Military/combat = stick with CLP. YMMV, and there is an obvious difference of opinion, but I can't fathom using 2-3 different kinds of lube on my rifle when 1 will do it all and do it all very well. If I'm ever in a situation where I've fired 600 rounds in the middle of a desert and my rifle "runs dry", the small bottle of CLP will be handy and in less than 30 seconds later I will be up and running for another 600 rounds. I carry with me a small bottle of CLP where ever the rifle goes, but I get that from carrying my rifle in a squad car in my former days of being a deputy sheriff. Enough Iraq/Afgan vets have mentioned "keeping it wet" enough times that it still makes sense to me to keep doing it. I've only ever run across one rifle that wouldn't function well only because it was dirty. It was a 10.5" suppressed full auto AR used by our SWAT team and had thousands of rounds through it without proper cleaning. SBR's run dirty, suppressed weapons run really dirty, and full auto weapons tend to see alot of rounds. This all combined with a guy who had never been shown how to properly clean his weapon (don't ask, I have no idea why they let this happen). This rifle had been cleaned, just not correctly, and buildup in the chamber was causing issues. It was well lubricated, but was malfunctioning due to the level of build up alone. On the other hand, I've had quite a few rifles stop running because they ran dry. While a rifle will usually run completely dry for a while, the combination of dry and dirt will lead to a malfunctioning rifle. Typically, a little squirt of oil will bring these rifles back online. So if my options are to use a lube that will stick around and still be wet after 600 rounds (Slip 2000, Lucas, Mobil 1) or use one that will burn off in a couple hundred rounds (I've never had to wait until 600 rounds for CLP to burn off) I'll choose the former every time. The oils that resist burning off also seem to keep the carbon buiildup from caking, which helps keep the rifle running smoothly. I also choose to use grease in a few spots on the AR because it stays put while a rifle is riding around in a case in my trunk, and I would do so regardless of which oil I chose to use. This has nothing to do with what happens after the gun is dirty, it just allows me to start with a lubed weapon from a situation where it is stored. It has also not been my experience that CLP (or any oil) "cycles out of the weapon" all the "grit, grime, sand, and other substances". CLP doesn't cycle out, it burns off. It leaves all the crap but also goes dry, which is the most likely way for a weapon to stop working. Better oils wil still be there, keeping the weapon lubricated, though also dirty, through quite a few more rounds. They will, however, slowly run out of the action due to gravity when stored for long periods of time, which is where my application for grease in a few critical areas comes into play. I suppose if you shot a few hundred rounds and then stuck your rifle back into storage for a few months the oil might carry out some of the buildup (if the oil was still wet) but I can't imagine why I would do that. You did specify "for military applications" so perhaps one in the military would. If CLP works for you, that's fine, but I submit that there are much better options available. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/16/2012 10:49:30 AM
i use tw-25b on everything, my weapons and the ones the army issued me. works great in iraq and afghanistan on my m4, m9 and m240. lots better than clp and after a long day of shooting cleanup is easy.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/16/2012 10:56:51 AM
Lukas Oil marine grease. The blue stuff.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/20/2012 10:14:04 AM
I use lucas oil stabilizer. Did wonders for my truck, and works well in the AR, very well, in fact.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/20/2012 11:34:01 AM
Originally Posted By Krinkplinker:
I use lucas oil stabilizer. Did wonders for my truck, and works well in the AR, very well, in fact. Just the stabilizer or mixed with oil? |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/20/2012 11:46:06 AM
[Last Edit: 4/20/2012 12:01:09 PM by Altair]
Originally Posted By Gregory_K:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Superlube synthetic grease. Where do people buy this stuff? Lowes or homedepot usally. link I went to Home depot looking for the Super Lube but couldn't find it. What I did find was Lucas White Lithium Grease. The TW25B reminded me of lithium grease so I grabbed the tube (8ozs). I compared the two when I got home (Lucas and TW25B) and they look and feel the same (right down to the separation). I'm gonna try the Lucas grease on a few guns and see how it performs since it is a fraction of the cost of the TW25B. ETA: None of the literature on the Lucas Lithium grease mentioned PTFE or Teflon so it may well not work the same. I'll see if Lucas will clarify what is in their product. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/24/2012 12:57:15 AM
Originally Posted By Altair:
Originally Posted By Gregory_K:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Superlube synthetic grease. Where do people buy this stuff? Lowes or homedepot usally. link I went to Home depot looking for the Super Lube but couldn't find it. What I did find was Lucas White Lithium Grease. The TW25B reminded me of lithium grease so I grabbed the tube (8ozs). I compared the two when I got home (Lucas and TW25B) and they look and feel the same (right down to the separation). I'm gonna try the Lucas grease on a few guns and see how it performs since it is a fraction of the cost of the TW25B. ETA: None of the literature on the Lucas Lithium grease mentioned PTFE or Teflon so it may well not work the same. I'll see if Lucas will clarify what is in their product. FWIW, it's a very safe bet that the Lucas lithium grease has nowhere near the teflon content of the TW25b ... and the teflon content is what's unique about that product. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/24/2012 2:21:04 AM
[Last Edit: 4/24/2012 2:27:01 AM by Blankwaffe98]
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Altair:
Originally Posted By Gregory_K:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Superlube synthetic grease. Where do people buy this stuff? Lowes or homedepot usally. link I went to Home depot looking for the Super Lube but couldn't find it. What I did find was Lucas White Lithium Grease. The TW25B reminded me of lithium grease so I grabbed the tube (8ozs). I compared the two when I got home (Lucas and TW25B) and they look and feel the same (right down to the separation). I'm gonna try the Lucas grease on a few guns and see how it performs since it is a fraction of the cost of the TW25B. ETA: None of the literature on the Lucas Lithium grease mentioned PTFE or Teflon so it may well not work the same. I'll see if Lucas will clarify what is in their product. FWIW, it's a very safe bet that the Lucas lithium grease has nowhere near the teflon content of the TW25b ... and the teflon content is what's unique about that product. Yeap,and there is a bit of a performance difference in common lithium greases vs. high end greases like TW25B which is calcium sulfonate/carboxylate complex...which is also why TW25B costs more. Known technical performance characteristics trumps looks and feels the same. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/24/2012 8:07:17 PM
Originally Posted By Blankwaffe98:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Altair:
Originally Posted By Gregory_K:
Originally Posted By Winn:
Originally Posted By Gamma762:
Superlube synthetic grease. Where do people buy this stuff? Lowes or homedepot usally. link I went to Home depot looking for the Super Lube but couldn't find it. What I did find was Lucas White Lithium Grease. The TW25B reminded me of lithium grease so I grabbed the tube (8ozs). I compared the two when I got home (Lucas and TW25B) and they look and feel the same (right down to the separation). I'm gonna try the Lucas grease on a few guns and see how it performs since it is a fraction of the cost of the TW25B. ETA: None of the literature on the Lucas Lithium grease mentioned PTFE or Teflon so it may well not work the same. I'll see if Lucas will clarify what is in their product. FWIW, it's a very safe bet that the Lucas lithium grease has nowhere near the teflon content of the TW25b ... and the teflon content is what's unique about that product. Yeap,and there is a bit of a performance difference in common lithium greases vs. high end greases like TW25B which is calcium sulfonate/carboxylate complex...which is also why TW25B costs more. Known technical performance characteristics trumps looks and feels the same. No argument, it was just an observation. Lucas got back to my email and said it was not acceptable for use on small arms, but didn't answer my question about the Teflon content. I still have pleny of uses for Lithium grease that are not firearm related so no harm done. |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/25/2012 2:46:41 AM
Originally Posted By Dee_NY: However after reading through this thread I definitely plan on picking up and trying out some of the above mentioned products such as the supper lube and TW25b. ![]() |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/25/2012 6:05:29 PM
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 4/26/2012 7:02:55 AM
I have been using ProShot Gold, but thinking of switching to Tetra Gun.
Phil |
|
|
|
Posted: 4/26/2012 7:11:11 AM
Originally Posted By locolopez:
bacon Damn!!! Beat me to it!! |
|
|