I was researching this the last couple weeks on eBay. $60 seems right for a used one. Check "completed listings", look at ones that actually sold (green price). I ultimately opted for the M962 and M961. The M95(1 or 2) is around 60 lumens, the M96(1 or 2) is I think 120 lumens. I got 2 M962s used for around $80 and a M961 NEW in box for $101
It all started because I wanted a light that was real USGI for a Mk18 Mod0 block 1 clone, started bidding...... won 3 lights.
ETA: Just looked, M951s are selling for around $75, but one guy was selling them for $49 with FREE SHIPPING!. There are a lot fewer M952s. A lot of M952s were new in wrap and going for well over $100.
$75 is probably a good price if it is a good clean unit. Like I said though, I decide to get the M96X because it is a superior light and cost about the same. Also watch out for people calling them the wrong name. I saw M96x being sold for $50 as a M95x and about half of all of them get the last digit wrong (depends on wether it has thumb nut mount or QD throw lever mount). Know what you looking at!
ETA: The pressure pad/tape switch cost $20~ so keep that in mind when pricing it, wether it includes it or not.