To check back in, I pulled the kit apart and there is pretty much no way to improve the grip on the extractor. I really wish I could find the original CMMG extractor to try again, I can't recall how it fit compared to the Taccom part.
But after making sure everything was cleaned, lubed, and free of rough spots I tried to run a magazine of Federal Lightnings 'blue box' and I got stove pipes, short strokes, and failure to reset the hammer. I tried another mag of American Eagle 'red box' and blew thru the whole magazine without a hitch.
I've used Federal lightning in the past but that was in 11.5, 16.5, and 20" barrels. Would it make sense that out of a 7.5" barrel that ammo is more picky?
Wanting as close to 100% reliability as possible, any tips for improving function with the weaker ammo?