I bought one of the 18" uppers from AIM about 5 months ago. Have had good luck with it, it's been 100% reliable so far, built on an home built lower, also Alex-Pro-Fab from AIM with my own parts I already had at home. The only thing I've noticed that's odd about it is the FF rail isn't Mlok or Keymod, it just has holes and slots. I haven't tried to mount Mlok into the slots yet, they look like they might be the right size, but hte slots are much longer than Mlok slots.
But, that 100% is only about 200 rounds so far, and I haven't patterned it for accuracy yet at 100 yards, I've only shot steel at 50 yards and all hits are on an 18" plate.
Edit: Sorry, it's compatible with my DPMS lower, that's why I bought it in the first place, so I would have interchangeability between my DPMS LR308 and the build gun. As I told a buddy the other day, if I wasn't already invested in a DPMS old style pattern gun, I would probably just buy one of the new GII guns and call it quits.