Author
Message
johnbush
Offline
Posts: 4
Feedback: 0% (0)
Posted: 1/4/2012 3:47:17 AM EST
I've been looking at the Palmetto State Armory kits and uppers. Has anyone seen or shot the 2 different barrels they offer. They have a chromelined chrome moyl barrel, and a heavy chomelined hammer forged FN barrel. There's about 80 to 90 dollar difference in price. I only shoot about once a month and maybe 200 to 250 rounds per, so I'm not going to wear out a barrel. I rarely shoot over 100 yds, but would like to be fairly accurate. Is the more expensive barrel going to shoot better? Or is it a durability thing? Anyone have any hands on with these or seen the difference??? It's my first AR and trying to find out whether to spend the additional money on my first budget build. Thanks

I'm not one who changed alotta of stuff on my guns, and will probably never add a bunch of accessories or take it apart and rebuild it into something else. If I want something different later, I'll just build another later. Just looking to try an AR for a while and get my feet wet.
Medicfrost
Member
Online
Posts: 1374
Feedback: 100% (152)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 4:00:36 AM EST
If you don't plan on shooting a lot, I'd go with the cheaper barrel.
User55645
Offline
Posts: 55
Feedback: 100% (13)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 4:02:45 AM EST
Shooting 250 rounds, once a month is still 3000 rounds a year. Not that thats a lot and going to burn your barrel out,but either barrel would be fine. While chrome lined barrels are the least accurate of the lot, they are not in any way inaccurate barrels. The lining is for durability. If your not going to be doing a lot of mag dumps and using your barrel for prying, get the non heavy barrel and save the money for ammo or your next build. Issued, M4 barrels can fire plenty of rounds w/o worry and so can you.

good luck and have fun
srob7001
Offline
Posts: 196
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 5:19:14 AM EST
I have the HF barrel, my g/f has the 4140 C/L barrel.......I can not tell a difference between the 2 when shooting them. HF is supposed to last longer...only time will tell.
brasidas
Online
Posts: 4647
Feedback: 100% (63)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 5:33:14 AM EST
[Last Edit: 1/4/2012 5:36:22 AM EST by brasidas]
I don't have any experience with PSA, but the two hammer forged barrels I have (DD, SIG) are a little less accurate than my ARs with button rifled barrels. The difference is small enough that it would be noticeable with anything but match ammo.
johnbush
Offline
Posts: 7
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 1:26:01 PM EST
Thanks, anyone else had a chance to compare the differences???
sleeper-
Offline
Posts: 8
Feedback: 100% (6)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 3:47:06 PM EST
Great question as i am looking at the two kits as well, for the extra $80 for the hammer forged and really no difference for what you and i will be doing with htme i may go with the cheaper set with the MOE kit. I too only plan on using the weopon for SHTF and rec shooting or camp shooting.

I am just not sure how the finish is like, from pics i have seen they look dull?
Peengwin
Member
Military
Offline
Posts: 1041
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 3:52:00 PM EST
Is there anyone on the site who has worn out a barrel? Excluding military weapons or folks who run ranges, or competition shooters.

I'm talking personal firearms, here.
This is not a signature. You didn't see anything.
johnbush
Offline
Posts: 8
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 5:24:28 PM EST
I read a little more detail into PSAs barrel descriptions, and I know everything is open to intrepuration. Some same chome molly vandieum, some say 4140 chrome moly, then there's the hammer forged. The cheaper barrels say air guaged and lead lapped. The hammer forged say HP tested and MP inspected. Can anyone give some input on the barrel descriptions differences??? Good or bad??? Thanks again
atblis
Offline
Posts: 53
Feedback: 100% (1)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 5:47:45 PM EST
I believe the non FN barrels are Wilson barrels. Perfectly good barrels. I have 4150 (Wilson I think), FN button rifled, and FN hammer forged. They all shoot well.
wrc777
Offline
Posts: 118
Feedback: 100% (1)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 5:58:34 PM EST
They also have some MP tested non-hammer forged barrels now.
dogbutter99
Member
Offline
Posts: 774
Feedback: 100% (1)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 6:34:50 PM EST
no :).

but we are talking about when SHTF.. you may only have a single barrel for next 10 generation.. :)



Originally Posted By Peengwin:
Is there anyone on the site who has worn out a barrel? Excluding military weapons or folks who run ranges, or competition shooters.

I'm talking personal firearms, here.


ankratz
WTB - DD Lite 12.0 - 19OCT2011
Offline
Posts: 1481
Feedback: 100% (310)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 6:53:51 PM EST
Here's an email I had with PSA. It was vague...I don't feel like my question was answered, but here it is if it helps:

Greetings,

What is the difference between the 20" 5.56 Hammer Forged, Chrome-Lined MP Upper
http://palmettostatearmory.com/2522.php which is in stock,

and the "Palmetto State Armory 20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper" which is
temporarily out of stock?

When will the latter be back in stock?


The differences are very minor, but essentially it is a difference in the
barrel manufacturers. The configuration that is out of stock is waiting on
barrels at this time. We should get them in as early as mid January and
then be able to hopefully be able to have them ready to sell by the
beginning of February.

Please let us know if there is anything else we can help you with.

Thanks for your inquiry,

Customer Service
Palmetto State Armory



Thanks for the info. So the out of stock ones are made by FN and
hammer forged, while the in stock ones are hammer forged but not FN?

Thanks


Not hammer forged are also non FN correct.

Please let us know if there is anything else we can help you with.

Thanks for your inquiry,

Customer Service
Palmetto State Armory
johnbush
Offline
Posts: 9
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/4/2012 7:22:41 PM EST
[Last Edit: 1/4/2012 7:25:47 PM EST by johnbush]
Originally Posted By dogbutter99:
no :).

but we are talking about when SHTF.. you may only have a single barrel for next 10 generation.. :)(quote)

If the SHTF I have 2 preban AKs and preban hi cap mags. I'm looking to get into ARs are don't want to spend a fortune on a first AR, but still want something that shoot relatively accurate and is fun to shoot. I'm just looking to get my hand dirty seeing how it goes together and what makes it all work. I have 2 stripped lowers coming this week and want to do a 14.5 carbine or middy for a fun gun, and build a varmint gun later to use when I'm at my house in Arizona. I'd rather save the $$$ for that build. Call it a learning experience that I'd like to come out of with a fairly accurate AR. Thanks



Chowser
Offline
Posts: 69
Feedback: 100% (17)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 12:42:47 PM EST
i bought the FN barrel when I bought my rifle kit from PSA. I highly doubt I will wear it out, i probably could've saved a little and got the regular barrel, but for my first build, i decided to get the FN barrel.
johnbush
Offline
Posts: 11
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 4:46:28 PM EST
Kinda thinking the same why. My other rifles that I shoot paper with, it's always been about barrel and trigger (and a decent scope) the rest is just icing on the cake. I'd hate to get a lesser barrel and save the 85 bucks and be unhappy with it down the road. I'm not as worried about the metal quality as I am the the lesser metal 4140 and 4150 may not be machined as good as the more expensive metals. I sent another request for information to PSA, but they never answered the one from before Christmas so any quess whether they'll respond this time.
PalmettoStateArmory
Member
Offline
Posts: 9187
Feedback: 100% (243)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 5:11:08 PM EST
Originally Posted By ankratz:
Here's an email I had with PSA. It was vague...I don't feel like my question was answered, but here it is if it helps:


I agree, and I'm sorry you received an incorrect reply to your inquiry.

The "20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper" isn't hammer forged.

The "20" 5.56 Hammer Forged, Chrome-Lined MP Upper" is also made for us by FN, but has a hammer forged barrel.

I hope that answers your question, and here is the link to the "FN marked upper" if you would like to read the description.

Palmetto State Armory 20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper
Glock031
Member
Offline
Posts: 244
Feedback: 100% (47)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 5:44:04 PM EST
Originally Posted By ankratz:
Here's an email I had with PSA. /span]


So which 20'" PSA do you own?

johnbush
Offline
Posts: 12
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 6:21:46 PM EST
Originally Posted By PalmettoStateArmory:
Originally Posted By ankratz:
Here's an email I had with PSA. It was vague...I don't feel like my question was answered, but here it is if it helps:


I agree, and I'm sorry you received an incorrect reply to your inquiry.

The "20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper" isn't hammer forged.

The "20" 5.56 Hammer Forged, Chrome-Lined MP Upper" is also made for us by FN, but has a hammer forged barrel.

I hope that answers your question, and here is the link to the "FN marked upper" if you would like to read the description.

Palmetto State Armory 20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper


Thank you for clarifying the email. My question is "are the 4140, 4150, CMV all machined to a spec that PSA sets and are they similar other then the alloy?
4schitzangiggles
Offline
Posts: 881
Feedback: 100% (4)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 9:45:32 PM EST
Originally Posted By Peengwin:
Is there anyone on the site who has worn out a barrel? Excluding military weapons or folks who run ranges, or competition shooters.

I'm talking personal firearms, here.


About 45/46 if memory serves.
To be young,single and lots of disposable income again...
splogan
Offline
Posts: 143
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 10:21:19 PM EST
Originally Posted By PalmettoStateArmory:
Originally Posted By ankratz:
Here's an email I had with PSA. It was vague...I don't feel like my question was answered, but here it is if it helps:


I agree, and I'm sorry you received an incorrect reply to your inquiry.

The "20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper" isn't hammer forged.

The "20" 5.56 Hammer Forged, Chrome-Lined MP Upper" is also made for us by FN, but has a hammer forged barrel.

I hope that answers your question, and here is the link to the "FN marked upper" if you would like to read the description.

Palmetto State Armory 20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper



The link takes you to a functioning order page, Can these uppers be ordered at this price???
c1eheh
Offline
Posts: 9
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/5/2012 11:10:00 PM EST
Originally Posted By splogan:
Originally Posted By PalmettoStateArmory:
Originally Posted By ankratz:
Here's an email I had with PSA. It was vague...I don't feel like my question was answered, but here it is if it helps:


I agree, and I'm sorry you received an incorrect reply to your inquiry.

The "20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper" isn't hammer forged.

The "20" 5.56 Hammer Forged, Chrome-Lined MP Upper" is also made for us by FN, but has a hammer forged barrel.

I hope that answers your question, and here is the link to the "FN marked upper" if you would like to read the description.

Palmetto State Armory 20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper



The link takes you to a functioning order page, Can these uppers be ordered at this price???


nope try to order and get sorry out of stock msg...

I ordered the 20inch kit w lpk and a2 stock. The barrel is made by FN hammer forged good to go, just FN isn't roll marked on barrel, but hammer forged = awesomeness :)

evlblkwpnz
Gunshine State Native
Offline
Posts: 3716
Feedback: 100% (90)
Link To This Post
Posted: 1/6/2012 3:07:24 AM EST
Originally Posted By PalmettoStateArmory:
Originally Posted By ankratz:
Here's an email I had with PSA. It was vague...I don't feel like my question was answered, but here it is if it helps:


I agree, and I'm sorry you received an incorrect reply to your inquiry.

The "20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper" isn't hammer forged.

The "20" 5.56 Hammer Forged, Chrome-Lined MP Upper" is also made for us by FN, but has a hammer forged barrel.

I hope that answers your question, and here is the link to the "FN marked upper" if you would like to read the description.

Palmetto State Armory 20'' 5.56 NATO FN Upper


I had one of these and it was a very tight shooter. I ended up wanting some other stuff and let a friend talk me out of it. I'm not a big fan of non-SBRs anyways, but I would buy another one of these if I decide to go "long" again.

I am a slave to my creations.... my image cannot be seen in them, but they bear my heart and soul - evl....