User Panel
Originally Posted By samuse:
Same exact thing I said about Keymod when and since it first came out. I got hit with all kinds of smart-ass remarks like 'smoking crack, need to see a doctor, have no clue WTF I'm talking about, etc.'. I'll say it again now. Keymod is lightweight, light duty, hobby grade, gamer/gear queer type stuff. It has no place on a working gun. I like BCM and my only working rifle is a complete EAG, I wouldn't put anyone over them when it comes to parts, but Larue and Daniel Defense is the only rails I use. View Quote I like the Keymod rails, but I have to agree that on a working gun you need the Picatinny rails. |
|
Mark it Zero!!
|
Any problems with BCM aluminum rail sections? I can see how the plastic ones might be able to move if really reefed on as plastic is only so strong and could fail. Plus the bottom of these rails are essentially hollow, allowing for displacement of rail material. Looks solidly poor design to me. However for the aluminum ones to move, metal would have to shear. Same with the BCM steel QD sling swivel socket. If it is properly installed, the only way it could move rearward is if metal has actually sheared as it has a "hook" that grabs the next hole forward (towards the muzzle), beyond the two key slots being used for the fasteners, to prevent rearward movement.
Seems to me that if there a weak point in the keymod system it would be keymod attachments that are not metallic, and/or those which are not solid on the bottom surface around where the nuts will pull up. If the bottom of the accessory is flat and solid in this area, metal from the rail is sandwiched between the nut and the accessory. The rail material cannot then easily bend, pull, or get displaced to allow loosening. But if the bottom of the accessory is hollow, like the plastic rail sections that BCM includes, it seems me that a decrease in attachment strength may be created. |
|
|
|
Patriot brown?
Originally Posted By tx1021:
That looks great. Pic thread: http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c249/Tx1021/image3006_zpsq3fg8t7a.png View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By tx1021:
Originally Posted By CtSmshr:
Freshly painted SOCOM 14.5 http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a584/GudOlBoy1/20150208_094027_zps67d6f170.jpg http://i1285.photobucket.com/albums/a584/GudOlBoy1/20150208_094254_zps620044dd.jpg That looks great. Pic thread: http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c249/Tx1021/image3006_zpsq3fg8t7a.png |
|
www.tacpack.com - Monthly Box of Gear for Gun Junkies
|
|
|
|
Reading about Lancelot's problems and the statements from others on here, I can't help but wonder if this was the reason HK decided to reverse the direction of their keymod rails
HK Keymod |
|
"It is impossible to make people understand their ignorance; for it requires knowledge to perceive it and therefore he that can perceive it hath it not." - Jeremy Taylor
|
I have a SLR rail and had a Seekins, I don't have any movement issues with at least the BCM VFG (twist kind, you can also adjust the screws to be tighter ), BCM Kag, Fortis light mount, IWC light mount, or the IWC qd swivel. Out of curiosity of this I put my but stock on the ground and applied pressure to these items with straight downward pressure, a slamming motion and by trying to add a wiggling movement as I applied pressure. I could not get any of my items to move on my rail choice.
Maybe BCM's material and finish is slicker or more prone to material deformation when tightened than aluminum? or its on the thinner side of the tolerance spectrum. I do think most accessories should have a locking piece between the two normal mounting screws. IF I applied enough pressure to my VFG it would break the VFG before it would slide off the rail. All i mount is a flashlight,sling and a VFG. I also don't have a problem with over torquing and I tighten the shit outta of things I have not broken anything and I'm hard on my shit.. The only reason I would go with a Quad rail currently is if I had NVD and an IR. I'm not a keymod lover and have some quibbles with it and only have one keymod rail right now(outta 5 rifles). Ive used/use quad rails( primarily DD) and etc and I have no concerns with keymod at least when its made out of aluminum. I flat out don't like the magnesium alloy choice myself. But some are hating on all keymod because of minor issues with primarily one brand, its silly. It be like saying all quad rails are crap because you had a bad experience with NCStar If all manufactures just make sure their accessories have a retention lug and captive screws, the sliding issue could be avoided as well as lost parts.Also with a retention lug the accessories would not sit flush with the rail until it was all the way on, meaning people couldn't tighten it with it being on incorrectly at least reducing user error. |
|
|
No issues with the KMR here, and alos did something similar with a VFG, but on a pic rail section. My direct attached handstop as had no issues and I use it as a barrier stop a lot as well.
|
|
|
Originally Posted By ASH556:
New 3gun/recce project: 14.5" BFH Middy. Going to chop the FSB and install a KMR 13. Offset MBUS Pro's and a Leupold VX-6 Multigun in an Aero Precision mount will round out the nice (and relatively lightweight) package: http://i854.photobucket.com/albums/ab104/ASH556/27D43825-FEFB-4642-9DD8-0E52BA29DCA3.jpg View Quote FSB chopped, KMR installed. |
|
|
|
Originally Posted By justinj1660:
<a href="http://s1279.photobucket.com/user/chipchipperson45/media/Public/4D533444-4746-49B8-A3E1-83FC498F7A70_zps4qbfb9lw.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i1279.photobucket.com/albums/y523/chipchipperson45/Public/4D533444-4746-49B8-A3E1-83FC498F7A70_zps4qbfb9lw.jpg</a> 11.5" BCM BFH upper assembly KAC RAS Silencerco Specwar 7.62 Aimpoint Comp M4 Spikes lower w/ SSA trigger B5 Sopmod Spikes ST-T2 buffer View Quote Clean. |
|
|
I did get a lot of off forum push back. You should read my email. That was the biggest part of my hesitance to post. It did serve a purpose though in that it forced me to try and retry certain things multiple times. The down side is that some of my friends in the industry have now put me on ignore.
With QD swivels most use the hole in the keymod to allow the stud on the swivel to pass through. This keeps the mount low profile. On one mount, when I tighten the screws the mount would actually move far enough that the stud would not seat. I had to loosen the screws, insert the swivel, then tighten the screw again. On a couple of occasions the mount would move with the stud in place. This traps the stud and the friction would not allow it to rotate. The swivel was then stuck and you could not remove it. I had to loosen the screws to remove the swivel. As the screws were tightened we could see the mount move aft on the rail. The BCM sling mount has a lip on the front that grabs the next hole forward. This keeps the swivel from working its way aft. You will now see two of the BCM mounts on this gun. One on each side. These seem to solve this issue for me. I did have an occasion or two when I would do a transition and drop the gun on the sling. The weight of the gun falling on the sling pulled the mount loose and to the rear. Again the stud was trapped. Using loctite and did not help. Again, not a BCM mount. If the hole and slot were reversed, then the mount would be pulled into the hole and not out of it. That would at least make the sling issue a non issue. Slings don't usually get pulled forward. Apparently the engineering shows that under recoil things move forward not aft, and that's why they made it this way. I use the IWC 2to1 triglide. I run my sling in two point and will transition to one point. I can't do that if its trapped. Also my work partner is right handed but shoots off her left shoulder. With QD's I can hand her the gun and she can swap the sling to the other side for her. That's the beauty of the QD setup sling, the QD lower receiver end plate, and QD's on both sides. Which is how this gun is set up. The sling can go from one side to the other very quickly. EAG sets up their guns the same way so that lefty students can run the same guns. I could use some other sling attachment system, but the QD works so well I don't care to change. And its not the mount to sling interface that is the problem, its the mount to rail interface. Don't misunderstand. I like the size, shape, and weight of the keymod tube. For most non working applications its fine. But I just can't trust it on a duty gun. Again, YMMV, and its just my opinion. Unfortunately, its one that I voiced in public, and it has cost me a great deal. People I respect took it personally, and for that I am truly sorry. The IWC / HSP light mounts have not been an issue. But they never get jerked around. If they take a hit from front to rear, who knows. I have not had that happen yet. There's not enough weight on them to force them to move. So far the KAG has not moved, but I have not really run it hard yet. I may swap back to the new VFG since my partner has small hands it that seems to work better for her. All my working guns are set up to allow it to be used by my partner if need be. So I have very specific needs. All that being said, this gun is a shooter. And it handles like a dream. Its fun to shoot and like all things BCM very reliable. Now if only Sherman and Peabody would let me borrow the way back machine. |
|
|
I completely 100% agree. Keymod is great for a lot of applications but under hard use, I've had lights and grips fall off.
|
|
|
I appreciate you taking the time to share this and am truly sorry that some people have shuned you for being honest. I've had issues with keymod accessories comming lose and for me was a mear inconvenience, on a working gun it's just plain dangerous and unacceptable. You shared your experience and concerns with keymod in a very respectful way, not sure why there was any butthurt over it
|
|
The more you care about something the deeper the fight will come from within.
You do not fight out of hate, but rather out of the love and compassion you have for those you are trying to protect. |
|
Not trying the shun Lancelot or anyone else and I do belive what he says, but its odd how as soon as he said it then a lot of people come out and say they have the same issues.
Coincidence or maybe they were waiting for someone of Lancelot's status to lead the way. Thanks for the info Lancelot, and for letting the thread get derailed a bit. |
|
|
Originally Posted By jukeboxx13:
Not trying the shun Lancelot or anyone else and I do belive what he says, but its odd how as soon as he said it then a lot of people come out and say they have the same issues. Coincidence or maybe they were waiting for someone of Lancelot's status to lead the way. Thanks for the info Lancelot, and for letting the thread get derailed a bit. View Quote I've said it in the past. I just felt like letting everyone else know again since it was brought up. I'm sure a lot of people were hesitant about expressing how they feel about keymod since it's the latest fad |
|
|
Originally Posted By Lancelot:
I did get a lot of off forum push back. You should read my email. That was the biggest part of my hesitance to post. It did serve a purpose though in that it forced me to try and retry certain things multiple times. The down side is that some of my friends in the industry have now put me on ignore. With QD swivels most use the hole in the keymod to allow the stud on the swivel to pass through. This keeps the mount low profile. On one mount, when I tighten the screws the mount would actually move far enough that the stud would not seat. I had to loosen the screws, insert the swivel, then tighten the screw again. On a couple of occasions the mount would move with the stud in place. This traps the stud and the friction would not allow it to rotate. The swivel was then stuck and you could not remove it. I had to loosen the screws to remove the swivel. As the screws were tightened we could see the mount move aft on the rail. The BCM sling mount has a lip on the front that grabs the next hole forward. This keeps the swivel from working its way aft. You will now see two of the BCM mounts on this gun. One on each side. These seem to solve this issue for me. I did have an occasion or two when I would do a transition and drop the gun on the sling. The weight of the gun falling on the sling pulled the mount loose and to the rear. Again the stud was trapped. Using loctite and did not help. Again, not a BCM mount. If the hole and slot were reversed, then the mount would be pulled into the hole and not out of it. That would at least make the sling issue a non issue. Slings don't usually get pulled forward. Apparently the engineering shows that under recoil things move forward not aft, and that's why they made it this way. I use the IWC 2to1 triglide. I run my sling in two point and will transition to one point. I can't do that if its trapped. Also my work partner is right handed but shoots off her left shoulder. With QD's I can hand her the gun and she can swap the sling to the other side for her. That's the beauty of the QD setup sling, the QD lower receiver end plate, and QD's on both sides. Which is how this gun is set up. The sling can go from one side to the other very quickly. EAG sets up their guns the same way so that lefty students can run the same guns. I could use some other sling attachment system, but the QD works so well I don't care to change. And its not the mount to sling interface that is the problem, its the mount to rail interface. Don't misunderstand. I like the size, shape, and weight of the keymod tube. For most non working applications its fine. But I just can't trust it on a duty gun. Again, YMMV, and its just my opinion. Unfortunately, its one that I voiced in public, and it has cost me a great deal. People I respect took it personally, and for that I am truly sorry. The IWC / HSP light mounts have not been an issue. But they never get jerked around. If they take a hit from front to rear, who knows. I have not had that happen yet. There's not enough weight on them to force them to move. So far the KAG has not moved, but I have not really run it hard yet. I may swap back to the new VFG since my partner has small hands it that seems to work better for her. All my working guns are set up to allow it to be used by my partner if need be. So I have very specific needs. All that being said, this gun is a shooter. And it handles like a dream. Its fun to shoot and like all things BCM very reliable. Now if only Sherman and Peabody would let me borrow the way back machine. View Quote I'm with ya. I'm not a fan of keymod for similar reasons that you stated. I do like the thin rail grip it gives, but that's about it. The only AR's i'm into these days (as you could probably tell from my sig) are duty type rifles. Meaning I 100 percent back you that picattany rails are a by nature more robust design than pic rails attatched to keymod slots. I'm not one for fads so I have no problem openly saying i'm not a fan of keymod. But I will say a friend that would put you on ignore because you prefer apples over the oranges that he sells for a living, was never a friend to begin with. |
|
In the absence of a plan, move toward the sound of gunfire and kill everything.
If it aint a clone or the gun being cloned, it aint shit. |
Originally Posted By Lancelot:
I did get a lot of off forum push back. You should read my email. That was the biggest part of my hesitance to post. It did serve a purpose though in that it forced me to try and retry certain things multiple times. The down side is that some of my friends in the industry have now put me on ignore. -snip- So far the KAG has not moved, but I have not really run it hard yet. I may swap back to the new VFG since my partner has small hands it that seems to work better for her. All my working guns are set up to allow it to be used by my partner if need be. So I have very specific needs. All that being said, this gun is a shooter. And it handles like a dream. Its fun to shoot and like all things BCM very reliable. Now if only Sherman and Peabody would let me borrow the way back machine. View Quote very sorry to hear that your honesty and integrity have cost you, but thank you for being true to yourself and others. you may very well have saved lives with this post. |
|
I can't imagine being so utterly clueless and then thinking you have a valid point to make in a public forum. -Lumpy196
Yes, it's exercise right up to 4:30...after that it's pron. -KILLERB6 |
Could you use red loctite on the qd sling mount? How often does a person even move those. Just make sure its like the bcm one with a lip to prevent sliding. I like quad rails and all but all I mount is a flashlight, sling and a VFG, the slimness and weight savings to me is worth it. All the weight I lost off the front of my rifle makes its handling a night and day difference compared to my previous quad railed rifles There are compromises to any system unfortunatly.
|
|
|
Originally Posted By ZoToL:
Could you use red loctite on the qd sling mount? How often does a person even move those. Just make sure its like the bcm one with a lip to prevent sliding. I like quad rails and all but all I mount is a flashlight, sling and a VFG, the slimness and weight savings to me is worth it. All the weight I lost off the front of my rifle makes its handling a night and day difference compared to my previous quad railed rifles There are compromises to any system unfortunatly. View Quote Yep, use well-designed KeyMod accessories and Loctite the screws. I also agree that using a top-rail mounted QD sling socket is a good idea. I personally like the Viking Tactics LPSMs, which are very low profile. |
|
Scepticism is an exercise, not a life; it is a discipline fit to purify the mind of prejudice and render it all the more apt, when the time comes, to believe and to act wisely. -- George Santayana
Never mistake a clear view for a short distance. |
Originally Posted By The_Hammer: I appreciate you taking the time to share this and am truly sorry that some people have shuned you for being honest. I've had issues with keymod accessories comming lose and for me was a mear inconvenience, on a working gun it's just plain dangerous and unacceptable. You shared your experience and concerns with keymod in a very respectful way, not sure why there was any butthurt over it View Quote Keymod is okay as a lightweight alternative, but certainly not a replacement to picatinny. I'm replacing my KMR this weekend. |
|
|
Originally Posted By jukeboxx13:
Not trying the shun Lancelot or anyone else and I do belive what he says, but its odd how as soon as he said it then a lot of people come out and say they have the same issues. Coincidence or maybe they were waiting for someone of Lancelot's status to lead the way. Thanks for the info Lancelot, and for letting the thread get derailed a bit. View Quote I've been voicing similar sentiments regarding keymod around here for quite some time now. I had already encountered a few keymod attachments that were even loctite'd come loose during hard use over a year ago now. I have always been vocal about it. Keymod has its place though. I have my third keymod upper on its way to me now. My go-to rifles all have picatinny handguards though. |
|
"They are not men, they are weapons."
It's not me, it's the BRD talking. |
A keymod accessory that relies on friction alone to prevent fore-aft movement is bound to fail under hard use. I wouldn't blame the keymod system for this though, that would be a shortcut in design by the accessory manufacturer.
|
|
|
Lets be clear. Nobody at BCM or IWC said a word to me. They continue to have my loyalty and support. Do not assume or infer anything bad about either company.
Others not so much. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Weldingrod:
A keymod accessory that relies on friction alone to prevent fore-aft movement is bound to fail under hard use. I wouldn't blame the keymod system for this though, that would be a shortcut in design by the accessory manufacturer. View Quote That;s what I was thinking that maybe some companies just aren't paying attention to how things work. I don't get why people would get so pissed if they care about their customers. Keymod is a new product and if you get no feedback on things how are things to get improved? If the accessory had a circular boss on the back to drop into the rail it would prevent rearward movement I know some companies do just that. |
|
|
Originally Posted By jukeboxx13:
Not trying the shun Lancelot or anyone else and I do belive what he says, but its odd how as soon as he said it then a lot of people come out and say they have the same issues. Coincidence or maybe they were waiting for someone of Lancelot's status to lead the way. Thanks for the info Lancelot, and for letting the thread get derailed a bit. View Quote I've mentioned my issues with keymod at one time or another, long before Lancelot made his post. I was simply restating them. |
|
The more you care about something the deeper the fight will come from within.
You do not fight out of hate, but rather out of the love and compassion you have for those you are trying to protect. |
"Basically, it's just a bunch of sloganeering morons congratulating each other for being so intellectual and free thinking." -cyborg543, regarding DU
|
|
|
Originally Posted By samuse: BCM complete EAG upper and separate complete lower. No Keymod. http://i851.photobucket.com/albums/ab76/sammuse/EAG/fbfeacd1-80ff-4f89-a0d8-d01f41a9a6d9_zpsy0s4dlrk.jpg View Quote |
|
|
First one. BCM Upper, Spikes Lower
" /> |
|
|
|
Originally Posted By jukeboxx13:
I truly miss mine. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By jukeboxx13:
Originally Posted By samuse:
BCM complete EAG upper and separate complete lower. No Keymod. http://i851.photobucket.com/albums/ab76/sammuse/EAG/fbfeacd1-80ff-4f89-a0d8-d01f41a9a6d9_zpsy0s4dlrk.jpg </a>" /> Mines still my go too. Although after reading some of this stuff i literally tried to bang a BCM KAG of my KMR. It wouldn't move, maybe if i used a hammer? |
|
|
R.I.P. Ssgt Fank. You are missed brother
|
1 confirmed kill: NAC_Instructor/plumsmugglers
|
Originally Posted By HammerForged: http://<a href=http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f165/joshuamarcreid/Mobile%20Uploads/20140610_201621_zps0fc0851e.jpg</a>" /> Mines still my go too. Although after reading some of this stuff i literally tried to bang a BCM KAG of my KMR. It wouldn't move, maybe if i used a hammer? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By HammerForged: Originally Posted By jukeboxx13: Originally Posted By samuse: BCM complete EAG upper and separate complete lower. No Keymod. http://i851.photobucket.com/albums/ab76/sammuse/EAG/fbfeacd1-80ff-4f89-a0d8-d01f41a9a6d9_zpsy0s4dlrk.jpg http://<a href=http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f165/joshuamarcreid/Mobile%20Uploads/20140610_201621_zps0fc0851e.jpg</a>" /> Mines still my go too. Although after reading some of this stuff i literally tried to bang a BCM KAG of my KMR. It wouldn't move, maybe if i used a hammer? |
|
|
Originally Posted By Lancelot:
I did get a lot of off forum push back. You should read my email. That was the biggest part of my hesitance to post. It did serve a purpose though in that it forced me to try and retry certain things multiple times. The down side is that some of my friends in the industry have now put me on ignore. With QD swivels most use the hole in the keymod to allow the stud on the swivel to pass through. This keeps the mount low profile. On one mount, when I tighten the screws the mount would actually move far enough that the stud would not seat. I had to loosen the screws, insert the swivel, then tighten the screw again. On a couple of occasions the mount would move with the stud in place. This traps the stud and the friction would not allow it to rotate. The swivel was then stuck and you could not remove it. I had to loosen the screws to remove the swivel. As the screws were tightened we could see the mount move aft on the rail. . View Quote Anyone who would give you a hard time over you telling the truth on a product that could possibly cost someone their life isn't a friend. I don't care what anyone says. You haven't lost anything of value, trust me. If someone was selling me something for my HD rifle and they withheld ANY kind of info that might make me second guess it due to a possible failure I would hold directly responsible for the outcome of a failure of said product. We are talking about lives potentially. You should out these people and they should be publicly shamed and shunned. |
|
|
Originally Posted By p226guy:
RRA middy handguards added, I need a light <a href="http://s1274.photobucket.com/user/philipdrye/media/1D0E9B7F-1130-44E1-B6B8-1640EF73AF90_zpsvcedm44y.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i1274.photobucket.com/albums/y423/philipdrye/1D0E9B7F-1130-44E1-B6B8-1640EF73AF90_zpsvcedm44y.jpg</a> View Quote |
|
|
Here are two of my BCM carbines. My other one didn't get to go to the range today.
Top is a my first SBR BCM 11.5" BFH upper, BCM BCG Stoner Arms Lower Inforce APL (soon to be swapped out) Magpul & BCM furniture Bottom one is my current favorite BCM 14.5" Blemished upper with Centurion C4 Rail, BCM BCG New Frontier Armory Billet lower BCM Comp Leupold VX-R Patrol 1.25-4x, Larue Mount Surefire G2x Troy Sights |
|
|
|
Originally Posted By Thesandstonefiles: Anyone who would give you a hard time over you telling the truth on a product that could possibly cost someone their life isn't a friend. I don't care what anyone says. You haven't lost anything of value, trust me. If someone was selling me something for my HD rifle and they withheld ANY kind of info that might make me second guess it due to a possible failure I would hold directly responsible for the outcome of a failure of said product. We are talking about lives potentially. You should out these people and they should be publicly shamed and shunned. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Thesandstonefiles: Originally Posted By Lancelot: I did get a lot of off forum push back. You should read my email. That was the biggest part of my hesitance to post. It did serve a purpose though in that it forced me to try and retry certain things multiple times. The down side is that some of my friends in the industry have now put me on ignore. With QD swivels most use the hole in the keymod to allow the stud on the swivel to pass through. This keeps the mount low profile. On one mount, when I tighten the screws the mount would actually move far enough that the stud would not seat. I had to loosen the screws, insert the swivel, then tighten the screw again. On a couple of occasions the mount would move with the stud in place. This traps the stud and the friction would not allow it to rotate. The swivel was then stuck and you could not remove it. I had to loosen the screws to remove the swivel. As the screws were tightened we could see the mount move aft on the rail. . Anyone who would give you a hard time over you telling the truth on a product that could possibly cost someone their life isn't a friend. I don't care what anyone says. You haven't lost anything of value, trust me. If someone was selling me something for my HD rifle and they withheld ANY kind of info that might make me second guess it due to a possible failure I would hold directly responsible for the outcome of a failure of said product. We are talking about lives potentially. You should out these people and they should be publicly shamed and shunned. If I could "like" a post... |
|
"It is impossible to make people understand their ignorance; for it requires knowledge to perceive it and therefore he that can perceive it hath it not." - Jeremy Taylor
|
|
1 confirmed kill: NAC_Instructor/plumsmugglers
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.