Author
Message
zombiegristle
Offline
Posts: 290
Feedback: 100% (27)
Posted: 11/19/2011 5:32:30 AM
[Last Edit: 11/19/2011 8:33:43 AM by zombiegristle]
I originally had posted this in the Armory, but now that I know bout the Industry section it seemed only proper for a review of SKD's gear to be posted under their respective section.

To preface this, it's my first real gear review and I am not an "operator" or any other such term synonymous with professional badass. I buy this stuff for SHTF preparation, training, and frankly because it's cool stuff. So while I will do my best to be fair and honest, I come from a background with no real-world experience or hard use, and I won't pretend like I know what it's like to get shot at or blown up in this gear.

I'm comparing my new PIG Bridandine plate carrier against my old Diamondback Tactical (or Battlelab, I suppose) Fast Attack Plate Carrier, first-gen model. Both are size large claim to be sized appropriately for SAPI-cut plates, and both are in Multicam (because all the cool kids wear it). I've had the FAPC for about two years now, and I've always liked it for having a really low "nylon-to-armor" ratio, as I call it. It holds plates, and doesn't have a lot of excess shit getting in the way like some carriers or vests do. Back when I made the purchase, I had an OTV carrier, Condor plate carrier, and a vest from Beez Combat to compare to, and the FAPC won out for being light and holding the plates comfortably and snugly.

So to start, here's me playing dress-up with the new carrier. It fits VERY nicely, hugs the torso like your life depends on it (which for many people it does). I have greater freedom of movement around the shoulders, where the FAPC has padded straps the Brig only has nylon webbing and doesn't encroach on the shoulder rotation nearly as much. The plates have absolutely NO play in them, as will be discussed further down, and the cummerbund holds it all very securely while still allowing enough stretch for comfortable, un-labored breathing. IF you look closely, you can see three slots on each side, where presumably one can attach a chest rig when they begin production at a later date. When I ordered the carrier, I also got a "Load Integration Kit", to attach a small chest rig that I had on the FAPC, but that didn't work out so well. This is my only complaint about the Brig - these slots have almost no impact on the carrier design that I can see, so I think having more than three to allow for more options would be a good idea. In my case, the LIK holds my plate carrier about halfway off the bottom of the carrier, as shown in the fourth and fifth images below.







Here is the Brig with my chest panel, I had it made by the good folks at Tactical Tailor for my FAPC. The idea was that I could mount pouches to it, and it would attach to the carrier with the front velcro and a pair of fastex buckles, so I could ditch the load and keep the armor. Worked well on the FAPC, not so much on the Brig. If there were more attachment points higher up on the front plate, it looks like it would have been feasible, albeit with a long attachment strap on each side.





Here are the two carriers side-by-side. The FAPC has a Camelbak on it, which isn't going on the Brig for two reasons - lack of attachment method, and a desire to keep it as slim as possible. I hope SKD comes out with a slim hydration option designed specifically for the Brig carrier at some point. Also, it would seem that DBT saw fit to not use MC webbing and velcro (or maybe it just wasn't available two years ago), instead going for the tan.



Here is a closeup showing the shoulder strap difference. The FAPC has padded "wings" on the shoulder strap, which do make it a little more comfy for standing still, but also add bulk. I like the Brig's plain webbing approach, leaving the style of shoulder strap up to the user through the attachment of separate pads or ballistic shoulders. Also, notice that the Brig shoulder straps are positioned slightly more inward on the plate - I'm torn on this one; On the one hand, I do have much greater freedom of rotation in the shoulder, but it does seem to dig into the neck a bit. This is probably not an issue if you're wearing one of those combat shirts with the mandarin collar.



Here I've put the front plate pocket of the Brig on top of the one for the FAPC, to show the difference in sizing (you can alo see the shoulder differences pretty clearly). The FAPC extend almost a full inch below the bottom of the Brig, which caused my plates to sag as shown below. My solution was to cut a foam spacer and put it in after the plate, to push it to the top of the pocket. No need with the Brig, it is sized EXACTLY for the plates and fits like a glove with no sagging or shifting.









And as a completely irrelevant fun point, I can store the Brig very compactly and without disassembling anything by twisting the front plate around and nestling it inside the back one, and using the cummerbund to hold it all together in a package the size of a large laptop. Kind of nice.

zombiegristle
Offline
Posts: 293
Feedback: 100% (27)
Link To This Post
Posted: 11/19/2011 8:33:50 AM
After I did my first writeup of the PIG Brig, piggly_wiggly contacted me asking if I'd be interested in reviewing the upcoming comfort pads and shoulder pads for said carrier. I told him I'd be happy to, and three days later a set showed up in my mailbox. I made it clear that I would be doing an honest review and not giving them preferential treatment for the goods, so please don't think I'm just promoting them out of personal interest - I didn't think I was even going to care for the pads, and figured they'd add too much bulk to be worth it. I was quite mistaken, and I now have a very positive opinion of these upgrades.

First up, here is a picture of my Brig with the new pads installed. The front/back comfort pads have a line of male velcro down one side, and are covered in MC fabric. I don't see the point of the camo on something that's going between the body and plates, and I think it might be a tad more comfortable if they had some sort of wicking material like Underarmor or Drilex or whatever the name brands are these days. The shoulder pads are a softer material, with two straps that wrap around the nylon shoulders. These small straps are both male velcro on one side and female on the other, and the pads are identical in shape so there's no fuss over which is the "right" or "left" pad, or which direction is the "front".





Here's a picture of the pads for thickness reference against an AR mag. The top pad is the shoulder, the bottom is the pad that goes on the plate pocket. I was pleasantly surprised at how thin they were for the amount of effect they have.



Here's me wearing the Brig with the pads installed. I didn't notice a big difference in the overall bulk of the carrier like I was anticipating, it seems the pads are stiff enough to hold the plates barely off the torso for airflow, but soft enough (I believe the proper industry term is "squishy") that they deform easily during movement and don't cause discomfort. The shoulder pads made a world of difference for me, and completely alleviated the discomfort of the shoulder straps digging into my neck. If you have a thick neck or don't wear mandarin-collar shirts under your armor, I highly recommend these pads so you don't chafe yourself to death.





Here are images of me shouldering a rifle, and squaring up with a pistol. I noticed that the front pads actually made this easier, by holding the plate off enough to keep it out of my shoulder but not so far out that it causes an issue with my arms. This was particularly noticeable with the pistol, I'm used to contacting the front plate with my upper arms and that seems to be less of an issue than usual. It seems the plate now falls in the natural angle between bicep and deltoid, following the curves of the arm.

I did notice, however, that the rear plate seems to pull away from my body more now, which may be looked at as a feature or bug depending on your needs. I enjoyed the nice breeze down my back when aiming, but I'm not sure if the size of the gap could pose an appreciable risk for people in harm's way.







Overall, my impressions were very positive. I did not expect I would be a big fan of these pads, mostly because I went with the Brig for it's extreme low profile and slim fit. The pads did not detract from that fit in any way, and the amount of comfort they added made a huge difference in the few little issues I had with the carrier at first. Despite my initial thoughts, after wearing the pads around my apartment (GF laughing at me the whole time) and switching back and forth between the two configurations, I think they are an excellent addition. I would like to see the comfort pads made with different material on the inside, since they're a comfort option I think a more comfort-oriented material than the MC-printed nylon would be in order. For myself, these pads are a must-have for the benefits in the neckline and pistol shooting, and will not be coming off my carrier.

I also just noticed that while sitting in my super-comfy recliner and posting this, the rear plate pads keep the plate from contacting my spine when I lean back. I think this is another great thing to point out, if you take a spill or a round in the back, the pads could keep you from suffering spinal injury.
SKD_Tactical
Member
Online
Posts: 14594
Feedback: 100% (352)
Link To This Post
Posted: 12/2/2011 12:35:31 AM
PIG BRIG Shoulder pads & AFC Pontoon Set are now out!!

SOS
Visit us at www.skdtac.com
& www.facebook.com/skdtactical
-------------------------------------
With Skill, Knowledge and Determination... You Will Prevail!
basko152
Online
Posts: 242
Feedback: 100% (12)
Link To This Post
Posted: 6/6/2012 10:06:52 PM
I've love my brig carrier. I've been using it for rapid "armor up" situations at work. When do we get to see some pics of the brig chest rig series. Sooner the better as I'm currently using a modified rig and swift clips and it's less than ideal.

thanks!