Recoil perception is a notoriously subjective subject.
I am a total wimp when it comes to recoil; I started shooting Highpower competitions with an M1 Garand, and after 80+ rounds (even with a shooting jacket) I could tell I was flinching in slow-prone. After competing with, and then shipping my AR's to temporary safety out of the PRK, I now shoot a 15 lb bolt-action match rifle in 243 Win--no more flinching!
My 30-06 hunting rifle with a "semi-varmint" contour barrel weighs about 10 lbs with the scope and a fully loaded magazine. I don't have any problems shooting 165 gr bullets at 2900 ft/sec; more evidence that recoil perception while hunting IS very different from that experienced during target practice.
A 300 Win Mag should be able to drive 200 gr bullets to about 2900 ft/sec, at which point I would give thanks for every extra pound of rifle mass!
_McUZI:
125 gr bullets out of a 300 Win Mag? What are you shooting them at, varmints out to 300-400 yards? Or do you prefer your venison "pre-tenderized" throughout (or do your varmints wear Kevlar)?
For longer range shooting, the rule of thumb is to go with the heavier bullets; even a 150 gr bullet out of a 30-06 beats a 125 gr from a 300 Win Mag after 500 yards (in terms of wind drift and retained velocity).