User Panel
Posted: 8/2/2015 10:47:48 PM EDT
We were getting ready to depart Idaho Falls on Saturday when it was announced that the flight was "too heavy." 3, then 5, then 10 people were encouraged to get off of the plane. If enough people did not get off the airline would start "involuntary deplaning." The process took 45 minutes with sweetening offers and threats that our baggage would be removed. There were probably less than 100 on the flight. How could the airline be that far off in its weight calculation?
|
|
What type of plane? I've only experienced this on small regional jets or propeller flights.
Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile |
|
Motherfuckers with 3 overloaded un weighed carry on bags. Cheap lazy fucks.
Kinda grumpy tonight. |
|
You want to find out what happens when you are too heavy???
Lol Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile |
|
In most of my ergonomics work in my previous life, human data such as averages including sizes and weights were taken from military intake statistics since it was fairly accurate.
Unfortunately the average American and the average soldier share little more than a country of origin anymore. My prediction is airlines will charge by the pound eventually. Just have to get past the SJWs |
|
I wonder if they were carrying any commercial cargo and didn't calculator correctly and made their customers suffer.
|
|
Join the airline's frequent flyer program and you are probably less likely to be kicked off.
|
|
Going to get to the point where everyone is allowed a single, small bag not over 20lbs.
Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile |
|
Quoted:
We were getting ready to depart Idaho Falls on Saturday when it was announced that the flight was "too heavy." 3, then 5, then 10 people were encouraged to get off of the plane. If enough people did not get off the airline would start "involuntary deplaning." The process took 45 minutes with sweetening offers and threats that our baggage would be removed. There were probably less than 100 on the flight. How could the airline be that far off in its weight calculation? View Quote I'm guessing that was maybe a Skywest flight or another regional? It happens and usually because of hot weather if it's something like a CRJ 200 but 10 passengers is a lot. What kind of plane? |
|
Additional cargo room sold off to mail/freight and contract obligations didn't allow for cargo to be removed, since the freight was time sensitive.
That's my wild ass guess. |
|
Quoted:
. How could the airline be that far off in its weight calculation? View Quote Kind of hard to do any weight calculations til they see how many kitchen sinks the passengers showed up with as checked bagage |
|
They also don't factor in the 400 lb land whales that are common these days. When I went through my ADX course, we were told to use 185 for men and 120 for women. No fucking way those numbers work these days. Factor in extra fuel for weather or delays and heavy ass bags, I can see overweight aircraft being an issue.
|
|
|
Quoted:
We were getting ready to depart Idaho Falls on Saturday when it was announced that the flight was "too heavy." 3, then 5, then 10 people were encouraged to get off of the plane. If enough people did not get off the airline would start "involuntary deplaning." The process took 45 minutes with sweetening offers and threats that our baggage would be removed. There were probably less than 100 on the flight. How could the airline be that far off in its weight calculation? View Quote Let me guess, Allegiant Air? The same airline that misjudged the fuel needed for a flight to Fargo, North Dakota and had to call in emergency landing? That airline is a joke; I once flew out of Oakland with them and they told us they had to ship our bags because the "fire suppression system in the baggage compartment was malfunctioning." Made me feel real safe. |
|
Somebody didn't pay attention to the preliminary weight and balance or there was a last minute change (fuel?) Also, if passengers were moved from another flight and central load planning was not notified, they may not have made necessary adjustments. Not a fun time either way.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
They also don't factor in the 400 lb land whales that are common these days. When I went through my ADX course, we were told to use 185 for men and 120 for women. No fucking way those numbers work these days. Factor in extra fuel for weather or delays and heavy ass bags, I can see overweight aircraft being an issue. View Quote We use the same weight for men and woman. It only changes for winter. |
|
Happened to us on a 110-degree day trying to get out of Reno, NV. We were about one more perk bump from getting off. They took 12 folks off the plane, backed it up to the fence, and took damn near every foot of runway to get off.
|
|
Quoted:
Additional cargo room sold off to mail/freight and contract obligations didn't allow for cargo to be removed, since the freight was time sensitive. That's my wild ass guess. View Quote Since it was an ERJ I doubt it had anything to do with cargo since it can't really carry much anyway. |
|
Quoted: Additional cargo room sold off to mail/freight and contract obligations didn't allow for cargo to be removed, since the freight was time sensitive. That's my wild ass guess. View Quote Even more rare you could load ballast and offset the change, but I've only seen that once |
|
Back in 2005 my wife and I took a Southwest flight from San Diego to my home town in Washington to spend Christmas with my family. We pulled away from the gate and started to move to the runway and then stopped. The pilot came on and said the plane was very heavy and he wanted to run the numbers to make sure we could take off. He came back on about ten minutes later and said Boeing said we were good to go. I was a little nervous but we took off no problem.
|
|
Quoted:
They also don't factor in the 400 lb land whales that are common these days. When I went through my ADX course, we were told to use 185 for men and 120 for women. No fucking way those numbers work these days. Factor in extra fuel for weather or delays and heavy ass bags, I can see overweight aircraft being an issue. View Quote 185 lbs? That's not even a full-grown man. |
|
Quoted:
What type of plane? I've only experienced this on small regional jets or propeller flights. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile View Quote I've seen them redistribute passengers to keep the plane from being nose heavy, but I've never seen anyone kick a passenger off on a jet for it being too heavy. Only on turboprops. |
|
I was guessing RJ when I read the title
CRJs and ERJs are low on my list of planes to fly on when I book my airfare |
|
Quoted: We use the same weight for men and woman. It only changes for winter. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: They also don't factor in the 400 lb land whales that are common these days. When I went through my ADX course, we were told to use 185 for men and 120 for women. No fucking way those numbers work these days. Factor in extra fuel for weather or delays and heavy ass bags, I can see overweight aircraft being an issue. We use the same weight for men and woman. It only changes for winter. |
|
Looking at flight numbers I now believe that it was a"CRJ9". (Delta flight from KIDA to KMSP around 1:30pm departure).
|
|
|
|
I've only had that happen once, and it was because the original plane had a maintenance issue, and the replacement plane had too much fuel on board for the short flight.
|
|
Gross overload?
Looking for volunteers to de-plane? You'd have seen a Speedy Gonzalez dust tail from my ass RUNNING up the Isle yelling "ARRIBA ARRIBA, ENDELE ENDELE, YEEE HAAAA". not a fan of falling out of the sky in a stall plummeting to my death Thanks, I'll pass. |
|
If you were on an ERJ (Embraer Regional Jet) or a CRJ (Canadair Regional Jet), then you were not flying on Delta. You were flying on a regional airline that was operating as part of Delta Connection. Totally different company, management, ops team, etc. In general, you are more likely to have performance problems due to weight/temperature/high altitude with a regional jet than a mainline jet such as the 737 or 757. When that happens, lightening the aircraft is really the only solution.
|
|
Quoted:
Gross overload? Looking for volunteers to de-plane? You'd have seen a Speedy Gonzalez dust tail from my ass RUNNING up the Isle yelling "ARRIBA ARRIBA, ENDELE ENDELE, YEEE HAAAA". not a fan of falling out of the sky in a stall plummeting to my death Thanks, I'll pass. View Quote Well the good news is you wouldnt fall out out of the sky. The bad news is, you'd never actually get into the sky and you'd run out of runway trying. If you're lucky the p9ilot will just take the on ramp and you can take the interstate to your destination. |
|
Quoted: I was guessing RJ when I read the title CRJs and ERJs are low on my list of planes to fly on when I book my airfare View Quote Gotta love that density altitude. |
|
Quoted: If you were on an ERJ (Embraer Regional Jet) or a CRJ (Canadair Regional Jet), then you were not flying on Delta. You were flying on a regional airline that was operating as part of Delta Connection. Totally different company, management, ops team, etc. In general, you are more likely to have performance problems due to weight/temperature/high altitude with a regional jet than a mainline jet such as the 737 or 757. When that happens, lightening the aircraft is really the only solution. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
The emb170/75 and 190/195 are pretty nice. Canadair=pass View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I was guessing RJ when I read the title CRJs and ERJs are low on my list of planes to fly on when I book my airfare The ERJs are nicer than the CRJs as a passenger but not as nice as a 737 especially the new ones ( I've been sticking to newer - 800s and 900s recently) I've also had fewer delays and baggage issues, sticking to mainline routes served by the airline than with an affiliate. |
|
Those jet engines can't move all that fat nowadays. Need jato rockets to assist now.
|
|
Quoted:
Embraer 145 was what I though initially. During the summer, it's not uncommon down here to see them go back to the gate after doing calculations to remove cargo and/or passengers. Gotta love that density altitude. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I was guessing RJ when I read the title CRJs and ERJs are low on my list of planes to fly on when I book my airfare Gotta love that density altitude. It's my Friday, I'm leaving work out of this |
|
Quoted:
Probably ASQ if it was a Delta flight. We get their CRJ's all the time down here. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
If you were on an ERJ (Embraer Regional Jet) or a CRJ (Canadair Regional Jet), then you were not flying on Delta. You were flying on a regional airline that was operating as part of Delta Connection. Totally different company, management, ops team, etc. In general, you are more likely to have performance problems due to weight/temperature/high altitude with a regional jet than a mainline jet such as the 737 or 757. When that happens, lightening the aircraft is really the only solution. CRJ900 from Idaho to MSP is Skywest |
|
$20 says it was over fueled.
Happens all the time. Fuel guy not paying attention and pumps a couple thousand pounds of fuel more than what the pilot asked for. Fuel guy gets the ticket from the pilot telling him how many pounds of fuel. Fuel guy hooks up and starts pumping. Either the guy stops paying attention or doesn't get the pump shut off in time. Pump shuts off with a dead man switch the fuel guy is holding, or at least used to..been a long time since I've done it. Most of the time the extra fuel isn't a big deal on the larger planes. A small ERJ and CRJ it matters very much. I used to be the Line Forman at a regional airport. In charge of all private and commercial fueling. |
|
Small aircraft have limited power margins and are sensitive to loading and density altitude.
|
|
Back in my crj years once, I was flying as captain from Missoula (if I recall correctly) to MSP. While enroute the weather went down unexpectedly in MSP and our flight was no longer legal to continue without an alternate and the required fuel. So we diverted to Sioux Falls, SD for fuel. Only problem was we had already had a very long duty day and were up against part 121 limits. But the company wanted that plane back into rotation. No problem, still legal under part 91 (noncommercial). We just kicked everyone off in the middle of fucking nowhere, loaded up any working and nonreving company personnel, and pushed back from the gate in full view of every single stranded passenger staring at us through the terminal's picture window.
Hey, it's not my plane. I just have to fly it the way the company tells me to. But the look on those people's faces was unforgettable when they figured out we were leaving without them. And there is no way to convince a hysterical woman that one set of rules says we're not safe enough to accept passengers but a different set of rules allows us to fly anyways without them. |
|
Quoted: Embraer 145 was what I though initially. During the summer, it's not uncommon down here to see them go back to the gate after doing calculations to remove cargo and/or passengers. Gotta love that density altitude. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I was guessing RJ when I read the title CRJs and ERJs are low on my list of planes to fly on when I book my airfare Gotta love that density altitude. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.