here is the recipe I got my inspiration from and a side by side with the brewers best kit I used. I added 8 oz of Molasses at the 45 minute mark of the boil as called for in the Porter recipe
I am going to rack to secondary this weekend so if you feel something's missing let me know
Found in
The Complete Homebrew Beer Book
by George Hummel
Colonial Porter
8 lbs UK dark malt extract
8-10 AAUs UK style hops (Challenger, Pilgrim, or Target)
8 oz Blackstrap Molasses
1.5 oz UK hops (Bramling Cross, Fuggle, or East Kent Golding
1 sachet Frementis S-04 or Danstar Nottingham ale yeast
Brewer's Best Dry Irish Stout
3 lbs UK dark liquid malt extract
2 lbs dark dry malt extract
1/2 lb Maltodextrin
12 oz Caramel 60 L
4 oz Roasted Barley
1 oz Magnum
1/2 oz Northern Brewer
1 sachet Danstar Nottingham ale yeast