Post above got me thinking about my checkride. Mind you this day started out with crap weather and a 100 mile flight to see the examiner. An examiner that is know for being "interesting" at time. I arrive at my destination, kill the engine and promptly fall out of the airplane because I somehow had the seatbelt wrapped about my foot.
So examiner grills me about anything and everything until he found something I didn't know. Happy I wouldn't kill us off we go flying. Airwork stuff all going pretty well except he kept nagging me about little things. Finally about 4,000 feet his says "You just lost your engine." Fair enough, trim airplane for best descent and start a turn to get a better look at the field below me. I happen to glance up and see an untowered airport not too far away. I tell him I am aborting field and headed towards airport. He gives me a
and "You sure about that?". Quickly get a distance and run the numbers in my head and off we go. Pull into pattern at 45 degrees and 900 feet, flew a semi circle pattern to the runway, perfect crosswind correction and a perfect landing. Roll off the runway at the first exit. He looks and me and says "I can't believe you just did that. I can't believe you made that landing. And very nice short field technique too." Then immediately says "You really shouldn't have dropped the nose so much in the pattern and preserved the altitude."
A quick short field takeoff and another trip around the pattern then off for more air work. The whole time keeps saying he couldn't believe I pulled that off. Looking back I should have just done the approach to field to 500 feet and abort thing. Then he nagged everything about my flying the whole time.
Finally we do unusual attitudes under the hood, no problem. I ask if I can take if off. "Nope, leave it on and fly me back to the airport. Fly until I tell you to take off the hood." Flew to about 2 miles north of the airport on a GPS runway track then setup on the VOR. While on final he tells me to take off the hood.
After shutdown he tells me "I can't believe you made that landing. But you are not ready for your instrument checkride yet."