User Panel
Posted: 4/27/2017 1:47:44 PM EDT
I'm about to go on a massive tool buying spree to supplement what I already have. I have most of what I want already picked out at the moment, but can't decide on a tool set for the trunk. These are the 3 sets that I was looking at:
http://www.homedepot.com/p/DEWALT-Mechanics-Tool-Set-200-Piece-DWMT75000/206510555?AID=11210757&PID=404255&SID=531186_desktop&cm_mmc=CJ-_-404255-_-11210757&cj=true http://www.harborfreight.com/130-pc-tool-set-with-case-63091.html https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00F4AVRGW?tag=vglnk-c102-20 I'm digging the Crescent set but have no experience with their tools. The Harbor Freight set looks tempting due to the price but I know the quality is suspect. The DeWalt is probably the last on my list because the Crescent set looks more complete for around the same price. Does anyone have any of these 3 sets, and if so, do you like them? Any other set to recommend? I want to stay under $100. Thanks. |
|
[#1]
For hobbyists and weekend wrenchers Harbor Freight is just fine.
|
|
[#2]
I've got that Crescent set. It belonged to my wife's (no pics) deceased husband.
It's not bad for what it is. It's what I grabbed when I went out of town a few weeks ago and knew I'd need some hand tools possibly. The only thing I have an issue with is the ratchets. The 1/4" ratchet has issues occasionally when it will lock up and not ratchet. I haven't taken the time to look into repairing it or not because I've got other 1/4" ratchets to use and just grab another. I would equate the quality of the Crescent set to an older Craftsman hand tool set. Not the new made in China stuff but the older made in USA stuff. I don't know about the quality of Crescent now and I don't know how old the set I have is but I've used it a few times and it's worked fine. |
|
[#3]
I have Stanley brand tool sets in my vehicles and in my children's vehicles. Better than Craftsman quality sockets and ratchets with 72 teeth gears and good wrenches too. I think the Crescent set you linked is identical to the Stanley set I purchased last Summer for my Son's car. I purchased a Harbor Freight tool set for my Son's vehicle and returned it because it was not as well made or complete as the Stanley set I finally found at Lowes.
BTW, make sure the tool set contains various pliers. The Home Depot set has none. |
|
[#4]
If you don't plan on using the tools much at all I guess you could go with the harbor freight ones. Personally I won't ever buy hand tools that are made in China anymore. I use tools quite often and I appreciate using quality made tools.
|
|
[#5]
Quoted:
If you don't plan on using the tools much at all I guess you could go with the harbor freight ones. Personally I won't ever buy hand tools that are made in China anymore. I use tools quite often and I appreciate using quality made tools. View Quote The HF stuff isn't bad. I buy their pro series. Its made in Taiwan, which from all the reviews I read said they are better than china. Comparing them to a lot of my sears craftsman stuff, its actually nicer.. |
|
[#7]
Quoted:
China makes pretty much everything anymore. View Quote And yes, a couple of those sell Chinese stuff also so you still gotta check |
|
[#8]
Cresent is fine. They're not awful horrible like horror freight, but they're nothing like my Snap-Ons at the shop. For occasional, or emergency stuff, you'll be good to go.
|
|
[#9]
The last set I bought from Home Depot husky brand none of the sockets or wrenches would stay in the case one of the molded case that things kinda snap in place I took it back and now when I need something like a nice tool kit with lots of pieces I wait till sears puts them on sale I keep a 200 something piece tool kit in all three of my trucks
|
|
[#10]
Quoted:
to do what? are you wrenching on a car? if so what car? View Quote |
|
[#11]
Quoted:
I have Stanley brand tool sets in my vehicles and in my children's vehicles. Better than Craftsman quality sockets and ratchets with 72 teeth gears and good wrenches too. I think the Crescent set you linked is identical to the Stanley set I purchased last Summer for my Son's car. I purchased a Harbor Freight tool set for my Son's vehicle and returned it because it was not as well made or complete as the Stanley set I finally found at Lowes. BTW, make sure the tool set contains various pliers. The Home Depot set has none. View Quote |
|
[#12]
Quoted:
I have Stanley brand tool sets in my vehicles and in my children's vehicles. Better than Craftsman quality sockets and ratchets with 72 teeth gears and good wrenches too. I think the Crescent set you linked is identical to the Stanley set I purchased last Summer for my Son's car. I purchased a Harbor Freight tool set for my Son's vehicle and returned it because it was not as well made or complete as the Stanley set I finally found at Lowes. BTW, make sure the tool set contains various pliers. The Home Depot set has none. View Quote |
|
[#13]
Quoted:
My main set of tools consists mostly of Craftsman that I bought 16 years ago and are holding up well. That is what I use for my maintenance needs. As far as the spare set, it's for the trunk in case the need ever arises while I'm on the road. Right now I drive and work on my Elantra (ugh, I know), along with my dad's 2007 Accent and a 2004 Optima. So mainly Korean cars. I have probably $600-800 of tools in the carts from Harbor Freight, Home Depot, and Amazon that I plan on purchasing. Mostly odds and ends stuff but will come in handy nonetheless. View Quote More over, if you're about to drop that much money on tools what are you trying to accomplish? Are you covering actual needs or are you covering "what if's"? For a car kit this is what I have in there (I've got jap cars) -Kobalt 3/8" drive tool set (the 20pc sets are fine) -Kobalt 1/2 drive socket that fits my lug nuts -15" heavy duty zip ties -linerless splicing tape -HF pro line metric wrench set -HF 1/2" drive 25" long breaker bar -HF deadblow hammer -HF 6" needle nose, slip joint, and diagnol cutters -HF vise grips QTY 2 -HF "free with purchase" screwdriver set -HF "free with purchase" multimeter -HF "free with purchase" magnetic LED light -assorted min blade fuses in a repurposed prescription bottle -HF 11" black canvas tool bag -shop rag QTY 1ea -penetrating oil QTY 1ea it ain't sexy but it is enough to do a surprising amount of work on a vehicle and be able to limp yourself home so you can fix the problem. It's also relatively cheap, so if it gets stolen or left somewhere zero fucks shall be given. |
|
[#14]
Lowe's offers a "Hassle Free" warranty on their tools. Yea! HA! They want a receipt, they black list your drivers license if you don't have one. Just go read over on Garage Journal. Each Lowes is run differently, and Kobalt quality has gone down and rumor is that they may be putting the new Craftsman line in Lowe's.
Honestly, for a set of tools that might get used, HF. |
|
[#15]
Quoted:
Are you starting out from scratch??? So far all the "kits" you've posted are basically one step above nothing but consist of tools that probably belong in the trash. Those are the kinds of things I'd keep in the house to do menial tasks if I didn't want to have a full set of tools but just enough to cover the basics. For automotive stuff they're essentially worthless. More over, if you're about to drop that much money on tools what are you trying to accomplish? Are you covering actual needs or are you covering "what if's"? For a car kit this is what I have in there (I've got jap cars) -Kobalt 3/8" drive tool set (the 20pc sets are fine) -Kobalt 1/2 drive socket that fits my lug nuts -15" heavy duty zip ties -linerless splicing tape -HF pro line metric wrench set -HF 1/2" drive 25" long breaker bar -HF deadblow hammer -HF 6" needle nose, slip joint, and diagnol cutters -HF vise grips QTY 2 -HF "free with purchase" screwdriver set -HF "free with purchase" multimeter -HF "free with purchase" magnetic LED light -assorted min blade fuses in a repurposed prescription bottle -HF 11" black canvas tool bag -shop rag QTY 1ea -penetrating oil QTY 1ea it ain't sexy but it is enough to do a surprising amount of work on a vehicle and be able to limp yourself home so you can fix the problem. It's also relatively cheap, so if it gets stolen or left somewhere zero fucks shall be given. View Quote |
|
[#16]
Quoted:
Lowe's offers a "Hassle Free" warranty on their tools. Yea! HA! They want a receipt, they black list your drivers license if you don't have one. Just go read over on Garage Journal. Each Lowes is run differently, and Kobalt quality has gone down and rumor is that they may be putting the new Craftsman line in Lowe's. Honestly, for a set of tools that might get used, HF. View Quote |
|
[#17]
Quoted:
Are you starting out from scratch??? So far all the "kits" you've posted are basically one step above nothing but consist of tools that probably belong in the trash. Those are the kinds of things I'd keep in the house to do menial tasks if I didn't want to have a full set of tools but just enough to cover the basics. For automotive stuff they're essentially worthless. More over, if you're about to drop that much money on tools what are you trying to accomplish? Are you covering actual needs or are you covering "what if's"? For a car kit this is what I have in there (I've got jap cars) -Kobalt 3/8" drive tool set (the 20pc sets are fine) -Kobalt 1/2 drive socket that fits my lug nuts -15" heavy duty zip ties -linerless splicing tape -HF pro line metric wrench set -HF 1/2" drive 25" long breaker bar -HF deadblow hammer -HF 6" needle nose, slip joint, and diagnol cutters -HF vise grips QTY 2 -HF "free with purchase" screwdriver set -HF "free with purchase" multimeter -HF "free with purchase" magnetic LED light -assorted min blade fuses in a repurposed prescription bottle -HF 11" black canvas tool bag -shop rag QTY 1ea -penetrating oil QTY 1ea it ain't sexy but it is enough to do a surprising amount of work on a vehicle and be able to limp yourself home so you can fix the problem. It's also relatively cheap, so if it gets stolen or left somewhere zero fucks shall be given. View Quote |
|
[#18]
Quoted:
The set I'm looking for would be for "what ifs" while on the road or out and about. That seems like a nice little assortment you assembled for your trunk set. View Quote Im not 19 or 20 anymore so the idea of doing anything more than a quick fix or patch job in a parking lot to get me home is less than appealing |
|
[#19]
Quoted:
Are you starting out from scratch??? So far all the "kits" you've posted are basically one step above nothing but consist of tools that probably belong in the trash. Those are the kinds of things I'd keep in the house to do menial tasks if I didn't want to have a full set of tools but just enough to cover the basics. For automotive stuff they're essentially worthless. More over, if you're about to drop that much money on tools what are you trying to accomplish? Are you covering actual needs or are you covering "what if's"? For a car kit this is what I have in there (I've got jap cars) -Kobalt 3/8" drive tool set (the 20pc sets are fine) -Kobalt 1/2 drive socket that fits my lug nuts -15" heavy duty zip ties -linerless splicing tape -HF pro line metric wrench set -HF 1/2" drive 25" long breaker bar -HF deadblow hammer -HF 6" needle nose, slip joint, and diagnol cutters -HF vise grips QTY 2 -HF "free with purchase" screwdriver set -HF "free with purchase" multimeter -HF "free with purchase" magnetic LED light -assorted min blade fuses in a repurposed prescription bottle -HF 11" black canvas tool bag -shop rag QTY 1ea -penetrating oil QTY 1ea it ain't sexy but it is enough to do a surprising amount of work on a vehicle and be able to limp yourself home so you can fix the problem. It's also relatively cheap, so if it gets stolen or left somewhere zero fucks shall be given. View Quote |
|
[#20]
Bump for more info.
My Civic Si is over 10 years old now, and need a Jap car friendly set of tools to carry in the car "just in case". Currently don't have any tools in the car. |
|
[#21]
Kobalt tools are nice. Good warranty if you live near a lowes. Otherwise anything will really work since it is a trunk tool set
|
|
[#22]
Quoted:
Kobalt tools are nice. Good warranty if you live near a lowes. Otherwise anything will really work since it is a trunk tool set View Quote http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=355715&page=5 |
|
[#23]
Quoted:
i gave up on carrying a full/larger set because there's only so much I can do when I'm away from my garage. I figure I just need to be able to fix some things or limp my carb back so I can take care of it there. Im not 19 or 20 anymore so the idea of doing anything more than a quick fix or patch job in a parking lot to get me home is less than appealing View Quote |
|
[#24]
Quoted:
I've decided I'm going to put together a trunk set similar to yours. It'll cost in between that of the HF and Crescent set I had linked, while being more comprehensive and of decent quality. Seems to be a nice compromise. View Quote It's easy to run down the tools rabbit hole and spend way too much money. I know I've done it before. I've actually started culling some of the crap I've purchased over the years. I just don't need what I thought I needed. |
|
[#25]
Quoted:
Most of the warranty stories I've read about Kobalt tools have been positive. There is one guy over at Garage Journal who has had some bad luck though. I think a few others too based on responses peppered throughout that thread but mostly positive. Still something to be aware of. http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=355715&page=5 View Quote Frankly I've never had any issues warrantying or exchanging any Kobalt stuff. Granted my sample size is limited to 2 ball end allen sockets that snapped off, but I walked in with the broken one to customer service and they told me to grab a new one off the shelf. No hassle, and no asking for a receipt. They only want the receipt if you return it. And frankly, if you're told you need a receipt for the exchange. Buy a new one then "return" the broken one later. Is it a dickbag thing to do? Maybe, that's up to you to decide. I once upon a time did that with harbor freight grinders. Then I got tired of killing them every 3-6mo so I just bought a quality one instead. Probably saved the difference in cost in gas money alone over the next few years |
|
[#26]
Quoted:
That's a pretty good list. I also keep a roll of twine, some bailing wire, and a few of those cheap ratchet straps. Also my multimeter is high quality because I use it the most. Ya know, batteries, alternators and such. View Quote I have straps/tie downs, bungee cords, 550 cord and tubular nylon in my car stowed by my spare tire. Never know when you need to secure some stuff so I tossed it in 12 years ago when I purchased the car. |
|
[#27]
Quoted:
Bump for more info. My Civic Si is over 10 years old now, and need a Jap car friendly set of tools to carry in the car "just in case". Currently don't have any tools in the car. View Quote Step 2: Have a realistic expectation of what it is you can feasibly do when you need your tools. There's only so much you can actually do with minimal hand tools on the side of the road, in the rain, and laying in the mud. At some point you just have to know when it's time to call for a tow. Step 3: After assessing steps 1 and 2 again, figure out what you need (and not extra crap), and buy tools that you don't mind losing or getting stolen. The truth is you probably WON'T be using these tools if you do Step 1 properly, and failing to catch something that PM would prevent would mean that it has to be something that doesn't deadline your vehicle and make it impossible to limp it back home to a better (and safer) working environment. I can carry everything I need to rebuild my entire car on the side of the road...but what's the point. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.