Author
Message
t3rror
Member
Offline
Posts: 729
Feedback: 100% (6)
Posted: 5/26/2012 4:23:23 AM

THE IMAGE ABOVE IS A PAID ADVERTISEMENT
We walked though a house today that we are interested in.

Background: We own our house which we paid 88K for free and clear. We are holding 50K liquid. The house we are looking at is being listed at 340K. We are going to offer 320K. What is your advice for haggling the price to people who don't know how to haggle?

The windows are old and need to be updated. The house needs a visual facelift.

This home is in the most prestigious area of our town. There is a home two houses down listed for 1.5M. We can't compare the two other than an enviable location
(the one we are looking at was built in 1930, the 1.5M home was built in 2006.

When buying a home what are good negotiating techniques?
The cold, unforgiving fist of reality craters the gut of another incompetent loon.

_MaH
gopeterson
Hoya Saxa
Offline
Posts: 12620
Feedback: 100% (5)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/26/2012 4:36:50 AM
Highly variable depending on the market you live in. You may want to consult a realtor as the commission will be born by the seller.

We recently put a contract on a house in the Northern Virginia area. Negotiations on houses is very area specific. In some areas it is still a buyer's market. In the area we are buying it is full price with little, if any, concessions.
I like to throw real blood on people wearing fake furs. That's just how I roll.
4ds4me
Member
Offline
Posts: 24
Feedback: 100% (2)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/26/2012 7:00:03 AM
Get an Independent appraisal and an independent inspection, not the guys recommended by your Realtor. Then start the process.
BozemanMT
Offline
Posts: 9898
Feedback: 100% (7)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/26/2012 8:43:51 AM
ok
you say the house is listed at 340k

but what is it worth??????????

how long on the market?
comparable sales around?
work needed?

and don't bother with a realtor, they don't even know their own job. waste of oxygen.

Appleby
Glenn Beck for President
Offline
Posts: 239
Feedback: 100% (10)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/26/2012 6:33:01 PM

Originally Posted By BozemanMT:
ok
you say the house is listed at 340k

but what is it worth??????????

how long on the market?
comparable sales around?
work needed?

and don't bother with a realtor, they don't even know their own job. waste of oxygen.

Great questions to ask, but your last statement reeks of the same type of thinking that says all cops are donut eating jerks, all Conservatives are racist white males and everyone in Texas has an oil well in their backyard and drives a Cadillac with horns on the hood. Well the last one about Texans might be true...

Seriously though....there are TONS of bad real estate agents. Tons. But there are a whole lot of good ones too. The ones who know their stuff, are honest and want what's best for their client, can save you a TON of money. They can even give you good info that might keep you from buying a house and save you a ton of heartache (and/or money) in the future.

The key is getting a good honest agent who isn't starving to death and looking to do anything they can to make a dollar. I prefer to know the agent very well and like them on a personal level before I ask for their help and advice.

Disclaimer: I'm a Tx licensed real estate agent for about 14 years but I have not been active in the business for the last 6-7 years and I never sold houses, only land and farms. I'll be the first to say there are alot of ignorant and even malicious agents out there, but that's why I wouldn't put my trust in one I didn't know or have a very good personal recommendation for. Same goes with home builders, mechanics, doctors etc.

Soonerborn75
Member
Offline
Posts: 237
Feedback: 100% (1)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/27/2012 2:07:35 AM
I would get a good realtor. This may be difficult. They are few and far between on my experience. Went through 4 before finding a good one last time.

I would find an equally good inspector. Find your own. A good one doing a second inspection saved my ass on a home i had already put money on and finalized the price with the owner directly (weird deal, i originally contacted him about renting it for a few months while we looked for a house). After the first one went through and ticked off a few minor things, he balked on some questions i tossed him and it made me suspicious. So i called around and got a second one to come in and he managed to come up with about 20K in immediate but not obvious repairs needed due to flooding that had been papered over with a little paneling, major landscaping needs for drainage and other things. He flat out stopped halfway through and showed me what he had found and didnt charge me a dime for calling it quits right there. Just agreed to use him in the future and i have. On a house that old I would make this a high priority.

The realtor is going to be the biggest help in trying determine your first offer. Make sure the realtor digs up any info on past inspections as any adverse items are required to be disclosed. I found out in that case above the owner knew about it but didnt think it was such a big deal. A good realtor will show you the best way to negotiate the deal, specific to the market you are in.

What do i know though, nobody is going to be skilled at this unless you do it for a living, which is why you have got to find the people you can trust to guide your decision. So absolutely get a realtor and a good inspector, heck even getting 2 or 3 inpectors that have special areas of expertise would probably be a good idea. Whats another thousand bucks when you are talking about 300 thousand.
BozemanMT
Offline
Posts: 9899
Feedback: 100% (7)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/27/2012 8:54:48 AM
[Last Edit: 5/27/2012 8:55:42 AM by BozemanMT]
Originally Posted By Appleby:

Originally Posted By BozemanMT:
ok
you say the house is listed at 340k

but what is it worth??????????

how long on the market?
comparable sales around?
work needed?

and don't bother with a realtor, they don't even know their own job. waste of oxygen.

Great questions to ask, but your last statement reeks of the same type of thinking that says all cops are donut eating jerks, all Conservatives are racist white males and everyone in Texas has an oil well in their backyard and drives a Cadillac with horns on the hood. Well the last one about Texans might be true...

Seriously though....there are TONS of bad real estate agents. Tons. But there are a whole lot of good ones too. The ones who know their stuff, are honest and want what's best for their client, can save you a TON of money. They can even give you good info that might keep you from buying a house and save you a ton of heartache (and/or money) in the future.

The key is getting a good honest agent who isn't starving to death and looking to do anything they can to make a dollar. I prefer to know the agent very well and like them on a personal level before I ask for their help and advice.

Disclaimer: I'm a Tx licensed real estate agent for about 14 years but I have not been active in the business for the last 6-7 years and I never sold houses, only land and farms. I'll be the first to say there are alot of ignorant and even malicious agents out there, but that's why I wouldn't put my trust in one I didn't know or have a very good personal recommendation for. Same goes with home builders, mechanics, doctors etc.



Just the latest example (I have tons of realtor examples)
My mother is selling her condo
Her realtor comes over with a full price cash offer for her to sign
I ask (over the phone) what's the contingencies? (mind you, I'm not a realtor)
the realtor digs thru and finds one for inspection (normal), one for a dog issue (reasonable) and one for an appraisal.

I said WOAH there doggie. Why does a cash deal need an appraisal?
the realtor acts shocked "why, they have a right to an appraisal"
Sure they do, but they don't' get to object.

So I tell my mother and the agent to pull the dates up for the objections to about 10 days (reasonable, we're not missing prime season being off the market) and totally remove the appraisal one. (because clearly, as the realtor nor my mother saw, what they are doing is locking up the property with a "full price offer" then negotiating on the back end with an appraisal. Do your own research before making an offer)
AND
i tell the realtor to get an entirely new offer sheet, don't just cross it out and write it in. (a counter is a rejection of your offer and a new offer, and it's important to understand that, most people don't, they think it's a modification of the original) and just remove the appraisal objection deadline. (they have a date to do the appraisal, but no opportunity to object)
Realtor says why? Because the other realtor is as incompetent as most realtor's they'll miss it.

Then realtor (it's 8pm at night, offer was put it at noon, way tight deadline. Again, to force an acceptance, lock the property up and then negotiate on the back end) says "oh, I can't, i didn't bring any paperwork, I just figured you'd sign".

it's fucking 2012. Go get your laptop and print it out. Go drive back to the damn office and get one. Make it happen. This is your job for fuck's sake!!!!!

Oh yeah, the other realtor missed the appraisal objection removal, just like I said they would. Mom closes next Tuesday, full price,

Realtors get paid only by the deal. They are out for the deal, not you. They do not have a responsibility to protect your interests either as buyer or seller. As long as you understand this (and most people don't), you can use them, like you use a bank teller. Don't ever use them for negotiating. They are out for the deal, not for your interests.

But they do NOT know their own damn job, almost no matter how long they have been doing it. I have TONS of examples.

At most, realtors are worth advertising fees and something for their time to show, but they certainly aren't worth the 6% they are getting.

4v50
Member
Offline
Posts: 27169
Feedback: 100% (5)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/27/2012 12:07:16 PM
Wait next year. it will be cheaper then.
lokifox
5.45 cause I'm poor.
Offline
Posts: 2104
Feedback: 100% (14)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/27/2012 3:39:06 PM
I am a little skiddish of interest rates after the election so decided to buy now.


I would to have liked to have more liquid cash to buy with but I think you have to jump when the deals are this good. 3.75%...... Pretty crazy times we live in.
Freedom costs a buck-o-five.
BozemanMT
Offline
Posts: 9901
Feedback: 100% (7)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/27/2012 6:46:09 PM
You realize what happens to prices when interest rates move back up right??????????

You make your profit when you buy.
lokifox
5.45 cause I'm poor.
Offline
Posts: 2106
Feedback: 100% (14)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/27/2012 7:48:11 PM
[Last Edit: 5/27/2012 7:48:39 PM by lokifox]
Originally Posted By BozemanMT:
You realize what happens to prices when interest rates move back up right??????????

You make your profit when you buy.


They tend to go down yes..... But the cost of construction on a house like I'm buying is about $140k, just a little under double what I'm buying it for now, so I don't think prices can drop that much more in my area.

The principle and interest on my house at 3.75% will come out to $370 per month. If I wait a year and the home price drops say another 10k, but interest rates go to 5% the base payment actually goes up $5!

I would love to be a cash buyer ––- IF ––- interest rates go up next year but sadly don't make quite enough to support my current living arrangements and save a shitload of money within a year.

I believe that there is a light at the end of the tunnel economically for the U.S. but booming industry means higher interest. Even if things go to shit I can stay in the house for less than a decent apartment costs.
Freedom costs a buck-o-five.
Appleby
Glenn Beck for President
Offline
Posts: 243
Feedback: 100% (10)
Link To This Post
Posted: 5/29/2012 12:47:45 AM

Originally Posted By BozemanMT:


Just the latest example (I have tons of realtor examples)
My mother is selling her condo
Her realtor comes over with a full price cash offer for her to sign
I ask (over the phone) what's the contingencies? (mind you, I'm not a realtor)
the realtor digs thru and finds one for inspection (normal), one for a dog issue (reasonable) and one for an appraisal.

I said WOAH there doggie. Why does a cash deal need an appraisal?
the realtor acts shocked "why, they have a right to an appraisal"
Sure they do, but they don't' get to object.

So I tell my mother and the agent to pull the dates up for the objections to about 10 days (reasonable, we're not missing prime season being off the market) and totally remove the appraisal one. (because clearly, as the realtor nor my mother saw, what they are doing is locking up the property with a "full price offer" then negotiating on the back end with an appraisal. Do your own research before making an offer)
AND
i tell the realtor to get an entirely new offer sheet, don't just cross it out and write it in. (a counter is a rejection of your offer and a new offer, and it's important to understand that, most people don't, they think it's a modification of the original) and just remove the appraisal objection deadline. (they have a date to do the appraisal, but no opportunity to object)
Realtor says why? Because the other realtor is as incompetent as most realtor's they'll miss it.

Then realtor (it's 8pm at night, offer was put it at noon, way tight deadline. Again, to force an acceptance, lock the property up and then negotiate on the back end) says "oh, I can't, i didn't bring any paperwork, I just figured you'd sign".

it's fucking 2012. Go get your laptop and print it out. Go drive back to the damn office and get one. Make it happen. This is your job for fuck's sake!!!!!

Oh yeah, the other realtor missed the appraisal objection removal, just like I said they would. Mom closes next Tuesday, full price,

Realtors get paid only by the deal. They are out for the deal, not you. They do not have a responsibility to protect your interests either as buyer or seller. As long as you understand this (and most people don't), you can use them, like you use a bank teller. Don't ever use them for negotiating. They are out for the deal, not for your interests.

But they do NOT know their own damn job, almost no matter how long they have been doing it. I have TONS of examples.

At most, realtors are worth advertising fees and something for their time to show, but they certainly aren't worth the 6% they are getting.


Look I'm not going to pick this apart piece by piece because I'm not going to get into a pissing match. I will say this, things are done differently in different states and even in different areas and markets within a state. A cash deal with a 10 day option period is standard. Most of the time that "option" gives the buyer the ability to back out of the sale for any reason or no reason. As for backing out if the appraisal came back unfavorable, I totally understand, but as a seller I would require that appraisal to be done within 10 day option.....meaning, I don't care what your reasoning is for calling the deal off, but on a cash deal (since financing isn't an excuse) I say you've got 10 days, make up your mind yes or no.

Yes it does sound like the agent is less than professional and less than competent according to some of the stuff you mentioned. But I stand by the fact that you are painting with too broad of a brush. I've already agreed that there are a TON of bad agents but that doesn't mean they are all bad. Also like I mentioned I would find an agent like I would find any other service professional....word of mouth from a trusted friend or family member. Maybe that's just because I'm a small town guy and that's how I do business.

They do not have a responsibility to protect your interests either as buyer or seller.

One last thing, I have NO idea about the laws and rules in your state but in Texas that is 100% absolutely without a doubt false. Anyone who believes that has no understanding of how licensed agents and brokers in Texas operate. If you are a seller's agent, you have a fiduciary responsibility of looking out for your clients best interest and the law is very clear on this. Disclosure is one of the big fiduciary responsibilities and if an agent knows that your house is worth more and tells you it isn't or lies or misleads you in any way, you have a legal case against them. What most people are confused of is the fact that in Texas, a seller's agent works for and is paid by the seller, they have NO fiduciary requirements to the buyer. They cannot lie or misrepresent anything but they are not charged in protecting the interests of the buyer. That's were buyer's agents comes in. Again, in Texas, they are required to do all the things a seller's agent is for their client, who is the buyer.

Like I said, I'm not in the business anymore and I never sold houses. I sold farms and ranches for many years and I never had any desire to get mixed up in the housing market and as I said, I'll be the first to admit there are tons of bad agents. But to paint them all with a broad brush and say none of them are worth their commission....sorry I don't buy into that line of thinking.