Nokona makes a great glove and they're made in the USA. I have a black 12 inch Kangaroo hide Nokona that my dad bought me when I was 13 in 1989. Other than some fading and slight pad thinning, it's still 100%.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide are very nice and used by alot of major league player. They run in the $185-$250 range
The Wilson A2000 is probably the most used line in MLB. $250 +/-
I have probably a dozen gloves and catchers mitts that range from $150-$350 and a 11.5 Rawlings HOTH is what I use the most. I did find a marked down 11.5 inch Insignia at Sports Authority of all places. It listed at $279, it was marked down to $79 and I scooped it up real quick. It's a very well constructed glove and will likely be used by my 8y/o for next dozen years. Insignia's are also made in the US.