Quote History Quoted:
@SCW -
Thanks for responding but I am surely NOT an architectural engineer so I am not entirely sure what I am looking at. Is that some kind of modeling application?
Anyways, can you bottom line it for me based on your experience?
@sitdwnandhngon
Ha ha, wish I could find a tree close to me in municipal San Diego. Sadly, the closest to me would be a few miles away and I think the park rangers might not approve.
Not too many farms around here either. Sadly, I am limited to what I can get at the local hardware store and further limited by my feeble construction skills.
View Quote
That's a structural analysis software. This is now the smallest project I've ever designed with it, lol.
Bottom line-
I'd do your second option, use a 4x4 arm sticking out and a couple of 2x4 knee braces on both side, like in your picture.
I think your problem will be when the pole moves in the ground, you don't have a large pole which means there isn't a lot of area to push against the soil, so instead of the soil holding it up, it will eventually just wobble around in the hole and make the hole bigger and bigger. What you need is a larger area to push against the dirt-
Here's a couple of quick sketches-
In this first one you would buy some 6"x6"x.25" galvanized angle iron, cut it into lengths about 8-12" (longer is better) and bolt them to the sides of your post. These act as wings to push against the soil and support the post.
In this second one you can essentially do the same thing, but if you don't have easy access to steel and a bunch of tools to work it, this uses wood. Just buy some extra 6x6 timber and bolt it to the main post.