Page:  / 17
Author
Message
chris65
Member
Offline
Posts: 1621
Feedback: 100% (3)
Link To This Post
Posted: 9/29/2009 10:52:08 PM
Originally Posted By DirtyHandsRob:
im curious, does your states allow you to have more than 5 or 6 rounds in your AR's or any rifle/shotgun? (Nebraska does not allow no more than 6 cartridges in a semi-auto firearm)

im looking for a 5 round mag for my AR before i take it deer hunting. any ideas?


Regular 20-rd mag –– remove floorplate, insert 3.25" tall block of wood or plastic, replace floorplate.
"A man with one AR is like a man with one arm." -me (pun intended)
Mannlicher
Grumpy old Gator
Offline
Posts: 1697
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/1/2009 1:40:14 PM
[Last Edit: 10/1/2009 1:41:15 PM by Mannlicher]
This year will my first time using a .223 for deer hunting. I will be using a Colt 6700 HBAR, a Weaver Classic Extreme 1.5-4.5X 30mm scope. I have loaded up 200 rounds using a Winchester 64 grain SP, H335 powder and Wolf SP primers, in a new Hornady case.
The load is very accurate in this rifle, under one inch at 100 yards.
Florida mandates a 5 round magazine. I bought mine direct from Bushmaster for about $25.
Nemo Me Impune lacesset
DrDeath
Offline
Posts: 2891
Feedback: 100% (4)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/2/2009 12:26:05 AM
WHat scope mount is that?
liaisons
?
Offline
Posts: 354
Feedback: 100% (41)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/2/2009 1:54:46 AM
Originally Posted By sbninja:
Yeah, I think I will try my AR-15 (.223) this year for deer - NY was thinking my 16" midlength(1 in 7) w/aimpoint. Or maybe just my Bushmaster M4(1 in 9) w/iron sights

Not sure which bullet to use? I have some Hornady 68 grain BTHP Match loaded up with Varget.

I also have some Hornady 55 grain V-Max ( need to load these)


V-Max is definitely not for deer.
RustyGate
Offline
Posts: 647
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/2/2009 4:24:45 PM
60 gr Nosler Partition......Both Federal and Black Hills offer factory loads, others might as well. They WILL do the job.


RG
rebel70754
Offline
Posts: 67
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/2/2009 4:59:33 PM
The 55gr. V-Max might not be for deer but my first 2 deer kills with the .223 was with them. Both deer dropped in their tracks after being hit behind the shoulder. The bullet was recovered on the far side under the skin on one deer in a squashed mushroom shape and just fragments in the other deer.
Argon3
Old Geezer
Offline
Posts: 2712
Feedback: 100% (2)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/3/2009 5:07:43 PM
[Last Edit: 10/3/2009 5:09:46 PM by Argon3]
Good thread for the positive posts
Daughter is getting set up to use an AR next season
Clone Red/Green dot
I have a 22 conversion to start her off
She'll be 6 She wants to go this year but does not want to go to the range so we are going to take small steps for next year

I'll be using 55 to 65 grn in a 1-9 twist
I'll see what it likes
It likes the 50 grn HP from WW but I do want a little more bullet even for the little deer in Texas

In put taken IM
Peace through Superior Firepower
Beta Phi Lamda Fraternity (BFL)
NRA Life Member
CHL Holder
CERT

Fortune Favores the Prepared
slodsm
Member
Offline
Posts: 43
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/4/2009 12:00:38 AM
I haven't taken a deer with a .223 yet but will try the AR out this season. I have however taken adult boar with 62gr fusion .223 and never had one take another step on a good shot.

I did have 1 get up and charge me when I got up to him on a 150 yd shot at a moving target. I didn't lead him "quite" enough for the neck shot and he took it in the shoulder so he went down and didn't move until I got close. Regardless, I believe it's a fine round for taking whatever needs to be taken within reason but with dangerous game, have another in the chamber "just in case" hahaha.
battlestick
Offline
Posts: 258
Feedback: 100% (2)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/4/2009 1:27:16 AM
[Last Edit: 10/4/2009 1:28:17 AM by battlestick]
Originally Posted By Argon3:
Good thread for the positive posts
Daughter is getting set up to use an AR next season
Clone Red/Green dot
I have a 22 conversion to start her off
She'll be 6 She wants to go this year but does not want to go to the range so we are going to take small steps for next year

I'll be using 55 to 65 grn in a 1-9 twist
I'll see what it likes
It likes the 50 grn HP from WW but I do want a little more bullet even for the little deer in Texas

In put taken IM


I know what you are saying here, but don't forget a smaller bullet with highter velocity has more foot pounds of enery at closer ranges. So a marginal hit MAY be negated. Look at the 62 Gr Barnes bullet, and its lighter counterparts, the 53 and 55 gr TSX.

EDITED, left out the word bullet.

PolyTechKID
Member
Offline
Posts: 3870
Feedback: 100% (11)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/13/2009 6:58:48 PM
Originally Posted By chris65:
Originally Posted By DirtyHandsRob:
im curious, does your states allow you to have more than 5 or 6 rounds in your AR's or any rifle/shotgun? (Nebraska does not allow no more than 6 cartridges in a semi-auto firearm)

im looking for a 5 round mag for my AR before i take it deer hunting. any ideas?


Regular 20-rd mag –– remove floorplate, insert 3.25" tall block of wood or plastic, replace floorplate.


Lego blocks would work well for that
Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin to slit throats.

H. L. Mencken
DrDeath
Offline
Posts: 2918
Feedback: 100% (4)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/18/2009 3:02:02 AM
Do you cut the spring??

Originally Posted By chris65:
Originally Posted By DirtyHandsRob:
im curious, does your states allow you to have more than 5 or 6 rounds in your AR's or any rifle/shotgun? (Nebraska does not allow no more than 6 cartridges in a semi-auto firearm)

im looking for a 5 round mag for my AR before i take it deer hunting. any ideas?


Regular 20-rd mag –– remove floorplate, insert 3.25" tall block of wood or plastic, replace floorplate.


DrDeath
Offline
Posts: 2919
Feedback: 100% (4)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/18/2009 3:06:18 AM
What about - FEDERAL 223 REM 60GR NOSLER PARTITION?
DPeacher
كافر
Offline
Posts: 12209
Feedback: 100% (5)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/18/2009 5:34:52 AM

Originally Posted By DrDeath:
What about - FEDERAL 223 REM 60GR NOSLER PARTITION?

The short answer: Those work very well.


The loooooong answer:

I made these posts in several similar threads. Someone should make a compilation of the threads on this subject and tack it...


.416 Rigby with a 400gn Hornady softpoint @ 2500 FPS at the muzzle. Range 150 yards. The bullet entered the left chest just in front of shoulder (deer quartering towards me) obliterated the top half of the heart and liquified the front half of the lungs, then came to rest on the ball joint of the right hip. The 10 point buck stayed on his hooves and ran 40 yards. No blood trail, not a single drop.

.223 Rem with a 60 gn Nosler Partition @ 2900 fps. Range 165 yards. Classic broadside shot just behind the shoulder on a mature doe. Bullet penetrated completely through the ribcage leaving a golf ball sized exit. The heart was missing 2/3 of it's top half with 6" diameter area of both lungs liquified. The doe ran about 50 yards. OK blood trail.

.223 Rem with 62 gn Barnes TSX @ 2900 fps. Range 145 yards. Classic broadside shot high in the shoulder on a mature doe. Bullet penetrated completely breaking both shoulders leaving a quarter sized exit wound. 6" diameter area of both lungs liquified. Doe DRT. Not a single step. (I had the exact same shot and performance using a 120 gn Barnes TSX out of my 6.5x57 @ 2900 fps on a small 8 point. My son had the same performance with a 180 gn TSX out of the .308 @ 100 yards. There is something "magic" about the high shoulder shot, 1/2 to 2/3 of the way up the chest/shoulder that just seems to work like a light switch. I think it traumatizes the spine and knocks the deer out, then they bleed out before coming to.)

7mm Rem Mag with 140 gn Nosler Ballistic Tip @ 3000 fps. Range 100 yards. Classic broadside shot on a mature buck. Buck dropped at the shot, then while my buddy and his young son were giving each other high fives, the deer walked off into a thorn thicket so dense we had to crawl into it on our hands an knees. We followed a blood trail that at times was so heavy it looked like someone was pouring it out by the Coke can. The trail went on for about 400 yards through the thicket, then into an open field where it tapered off to a few drops then stopped. The deer was never recovered. It's as if it "rubbed some dirt on it and walked it off". (The year before, my son shot a nice doe with a .223 62 gn TSX from the exact same blind and had the exact same results, except the blood trail only went about 100 yards. The folks who own that property say they have lost DOZENS of deer the same way from that blind with 7x57, .270, .308... As hard as we all try to recover every animal shot, there will always be a few that haunt us.)

I've seen enough deer shot with the .223 to know that a 60 gn or heavier bullet designed for use on deer sized game will leave a wound channel that is virtually indistinguishable from that of a .270 or .30-06 IN THE CASE OF BROADSIDE SHOTS WITH RANGES OF 250 YARDS OR LESS. I've seen enough deer shot to know that you can NEVER count on a blood trail even when using a .416 Rigby. Heart shots work, but the deer is going to run for 30 to 200 yards, maybe more. High shoulder shots tend to be DRT but you are going to waste a large part of both shoulders. There's not a cartridge in existence that doesn't have at least 1 "failure" on it's record.

.223 with 60 gn and heavier bullets will work just fine if the hunter is patient enough to wait for a shot that will pass through both lungs. A flubbed shot with ANY cartridge has a high potential for unrecovered game.


I know there is a bit (quite possibly a LOT) of disbelief/hesitation for a lot of folks to trust a .223 to properly do the job on deer sized animals. I WAS ONE OF THOSE PEOPLE. I grew up when most of the experienced hunters viewed .243 and 6mm Rem as marginal, and PROPER deer cartridges started with the .257 Roberts.

Given the projectiles available in most areas in the 70's and 80's, old cup and core designs the best of the era being the Remington Core Lockt and the Hornady Interlock, the seasoned hunters were probably right. Sure, the Nosler Partition had been available to handloaders for about 40 years, but just as today the VAST majority of hunters bought their ammo from the local sporting goods counter at Walmart or a local Mom & Pop gun shop, and they probably decided to buy whichever box was cheapest. The major manufactures didn't really start offering their 'premium' bullets until the late 80's early 90's, and if the local shop even carried them, they were usually twice the price of the standard offering (that really hasn't changed over the years). Remember, this was WAY before the internet and the Cabela's and Bass Pro mega marts.

Back then, the manufactures marketed ammo and rifles tailored to specific niches. They loaded .223, .22-250, .243/6mm ammo with light weight thin jacketed bullets, and they offered rifles in those calibers with slow twist 1/12 or 1/14 barrels. Using those combinations on deer sized game most certainly was a BAD idea. Remember when a 55 gn .224" was HEAVY? What about 80 gn .243"... They didn't offer anything else because their slow twist factory barrels couldn't stabilize anything heavier.

Technology has made BIG advances over the last 30 years. Electronics and data communications have been the leaders of the pack, but the bullet tinkerers have been busy too. The current bullet technology is FAR ahead of the old cup and core designs. Bonded core bullets like the Swift Scirocco, Hornady Interbond, Nosler Accubond, Remington Core Lockt Ultra Bond are marvelous. The monolithic copper bullets like the Barnes TSX and the Hornady GMX are astoundingly effective.

We can thank the custom barrel makers for the fast twist barrels we have today and the custom bullet makers for the heavier, bonded core/monolithic copper bullets that are available. Today's .223 Rem loaded with a 70 gn Barnes TSX coupled with a 1/7 twist barrel is VASTLY different than the .223 rifle and ammo on the shelves in 1980.

The very first deer I saw taken with a .223 was shot by the now ex-wife of a well known member here. She wanted to hunt, but the .270 her husband was using kicked too much for her to handle. I had been reading of many folks using .223 loaded with quality 60 gn and heavier bullets for a few years, and I decided to load up some 60 gn Nosler Partitions with an eye on shooting a deer with them. Well, as things worked out, Nicole was the one who actually got to do it. We spent about an hour on the 100 yard practice range making sure she could keep every shot in a 4" circle, and we talked all about whitetail anatomy and bullet placement. Nicole went out to the stand that afternoon and shot a small doe at 40 yards. The deer was quartering away from her. The bullet entered on the left side about 3 ribs up from the diaphragm, it obliterated the liver and both lungs, then broke the right shoulder leaving a golf ball sized exit wound. She said the deer dropped in its tracks and kicked for a few seconds, but died before she could reload. That deer was hanging in the skinning shed next to another one that had been dropped with a .270 when I got back to the ranch house (empty handed, I should add). The wound channels were VERY similar. She was quite happy with herself and she had every right to be. She went out to that stand alone and cleanly killed her first deer without ANY assistance.

In all honesty, the .223 worked a LOT better than I ever thought it would. Over the years the range has increased but the results have remained consistent. I'm comfortable that a properly loaded .223 is very capable of cleanly killing 250 lb whitetails out to 250 yards AS LONG AS THE HUNTER HAS THE PATIENCE TO WAIT FOR A REASONABLE BROADSIDE SHOT AND THE SKILL TO PUT THE BULLET THROUGH BOTH LUNGS.
"There is no American culture anymore and, without a culture, there is nothing to fight for other than mere survival." ~ Jarhead_22
mike103
Team Member
Offline
Posts: 3584
Feedback: 100% (1)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/18/2009 11:06:38 AM
Anyone have hands on experience with the Remington 55 grain Soft point loads?
danc46

Offline
Posts: 16613
Feedback: 100% (33)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/18/2009 11:42:26 AM
Originally Posted By mike103:
Anyone have hands on experience with the Remington 55 grain Soft point loads?


Contact Remington Customer Service and ask what they would recommend from their ammunition line to use for whitetail deer hunting.
You'll be a lot better off if you do.

My epitaph will read:
Dan was a really big asshole.
Chuck said so.
chris65
Member
Offline
Posts: 1661
Feedback: 100% (3)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/20/2009 12:19:07 AM
Originally Posted By DrDeath:
Do you cut the spring??

Originally Posted By chris65:
Originally Posted By DirtyHandsRob:
im curious, does your states allow you to have more than 5 or 6 rounds in your AR's or any rifle/shotgun? (Nebraska does not allow no more than 6 cartridges in a semi-auto firearm)

im looking for a 5 round mag for my AR before i take it deer hunting. any ideas?


Regular 20-rd mag –– remove floorplate, insert 3.25" tall block of wood or plastic, replace floorplate.




No cutting of mag spring. It is just like being fully loaded with rounds, you are taking up space used by rounds six thru twenty with the inserted block. I like the Leggos idea posted above too, press a few together, glue, and sand for exact fit.
"A man with one AR is like a man with one arm." -me (pun intended)
DrDeath
Offline
Posts: 2930
Feedback: 100% (4)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/20/2009 1:09:21 AM
I could not find any of the below listed Fed 60g Nosler , but I did find some Federal Premium Tactical 62g Bonded SP .......Opinions???

Originally Posted By DrDeath:
What about - FEDERAL 223 REM 60GR NOSLER PARTITION?


DanParker
Member
Offline
Posts: 1828
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/20/2009 5:18:40 AM
[Last Edit: 10/20/2009 12:15:47 PM by DanParker]
Originally Posted By DrDeath:
I could not find any of the below listed Fed 60g Nosler , but I did find some Federal Premium Tactical 62g Bonded SP .......Opinions???

http://www.ar15.com/forums/topic.html?b=10&f=23&t=628630
danc46

Offline
Posts: 16627
Feedback: 100% (33)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/20/2009 11:12:25 AM
Originally Posted By DrDeath:
I could not find any of the below listed Fed 60g Nosler , but I did find some Federal Premium Tactical 62g Bonded SP .......Opinions???

Originally Posted By DrDeath:
What about - FEDERAL 223 REM 60GR NOSLER PARTITION?




If you have question about Federal ammo in 223, contact Federal yourself and ask them.
http://www.federalpremium.com/general/our_company/contact_us.aspx
I contacted them, asked them what three bullets in 223 they manufacture would they recommend for deer hunting.
Their response said only the 60 gr Nosler.
By all means, don't take my word for it, or anyone else's. Contact the manufacturer of the ammo and see what they say.

My epitaph will read:
Dan was a really big asshole.
Chuck said so.
Combat_Jack
Abolish the Corporate Income Tax
Offline
Posts: 45543
Feedback: 100% (13)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/21/2009 12:07:24 AM
Originally Posted By danc46:
Originally Posted By DrDeath:
I could not find any of the below listed Fed 60g Nosler , but I did find some Federal Premium Tactical 62g Bonded SP .......Opinions???

Originally Posted By DrDeath:
What about - FEDERAL 223 REM 60GR NOSLER PARTITION?




If you have question about Federal ammo in 223, contact Federal yourself and ask them.
http://www.federalpremium.com/general/our_company/contact_us.aspx
I contacted them, asked them what three bullets in 223 they manufacture would they recommend for deer hunting.
Their response said only the 60 gr Nosler.
By all means, don't take my word for it, or anyone else's. Contact the manufacturer of the ammo and see what they say.


I have a box of .223 55gr TSXs from the Premium line, they best be recommended for deer, cause they have a whitetail on the box!
"We learn history not in order to know how to behave or how to succeed, but to know who we are". Leszek Kolakowski, 23OCT1927 – 17JUL2009
walther1978
Offline
Posts: 1034
Feedback: 100% (2)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/21/2009 1:08:51 AM
I just purchased 50 55grain TSX and 50 62 grain TSX's. I plan on loading them this week with varget and w748, and working different powder weights to see what works best out of my heavy barrel 1/9 16" RRA.

I'll be using those bullets with a Mueller 4.5x14x40 scope. Plan on taking a shot under 200 yards, preferrably 50 or less. It's only my 2nd season so I'm going to over power the scope to make sure I get proper shot placement.

Will also be my first time reloading. Wish me luck.
DanParker
Member
Offline
Posts: 1833
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/21/2009 8:30:52 AM
Originally Posted By walther1978:
I just purchased 50 55grain TSX and 50 62 grain TSX's. I plan on loading them this week with varget and w748, and working different powder weights to see what works best out of my heavy barrel 1/9 16" RRA.

I'll be using those bullets with a Mueller 4.5x14x40 scope. Plan on taking a shot under 200 yards, preferrably 50 or less. It's only my 2nd season so I'm going to over power the scope to make sure I get proper shot placement.

Will also be my first time reloading. Wish me luck.

Barnes states that a 1:8 or faster is required to stabilize 62 gr. and heavier TSXs, so you may have some issues with your 2nd set of loads.
DrDeath
Offline
Posts: 2934
Feedback: 100% (4)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/21/2009 12:33:17 PM
Are you talking the CorBon 223 -62G BARNEs X-Bullet round??

.223 Rem with a 60 gn Nosler Partition @ 2900 fps. Range 165 yards. Classic broadside shot just behind the shoulder on a mature doe. Bullet penetrated completely through the ribcage leaving a golf ball sized exit. The heart was missing 2/3 of it's top half with 6" diameter area of both lungs liquified. The doe ran about 50 yards. OK blood trail.

.223 Rem with 62 gn Barnes TSX @ 2900 fps. Range 145 yards. Classic broadside shot high in the shoulder on a mature doe. Bullet penetrated completely breaking both shoulders leaving a quarter sized exit wound. 6" diameter area of both lungs liquified. Doe DRT. Not a single step. (I had the exact same shot and performance using a 120 gn Barnes TSX out of my 6.5x57 @ 2900 fps on a small 8 point. My son had the same performance with a 180 gn TSX out of the .308 @ 100 yards. There is something "magic" about the high shoulder shot, 1/2 to 2/3 of the way up the chest/shoulder that just seems to work like a light switch. I think it traumatizes the spine and knocks the deer out, then they bleed out before coming to.)

7mm Rem Mag with 140 gn Nosler Ballistic Tip @ 3000 fps. Range 100 yards. Classic broadside shot on a mature buck. Buck dropped at the shot, then while my buddy and his young son were giving each other high fives, the deer walked off into a thorn thicket so dense we had to crawl into it on our hands an knees. We followed a blood trail that at times was so heavy it looked like someone was pouring it out by the Coke can. The trail went on for about 400 yards through the thicket, then into an open field where it tapered off to a few drops then stopped. The deer was never recovered. It's as if it "rubbed some dirt on it and walked it off". (The year before, my son shot a nice doe with a .223 62 gn TSX from the exact same blind and had the exact same results, except the blood trail only went about 100 yards. The folks who own that property say they have lost DOZENS of deer the same way from that blind with 7x57, .270, .308... As hard as we all try to recover every animal shot, there will always be a few that haunt us.)

I've seen enough deer shot with the .223 to know that a 60 gn or heavier bullet designed for use on deer sized game will leave a wound channel that is virtually indistinguishable from that of a .270 or .30-06 IN THE CASE OF BROADSIDE SHOTS WITH RANGES OF 250 YARDS OR LESS. I've seen enough deer shot to know that you can NEVER count on a blood trail even when using a .416 Rigby. Heart shots work, but the deer is going to run for 30 to 200 yards, maybe more. High shoulder shots tend to be DRT but you are going to waste a large part of both shoulders. There's not a cartridge in existence that doesn't have at least 1 "failure" on it's record.

.223 with 60 gn and heavier bullets will work just fine if the hunter is patient enough to wait for a shot that will pass through both lungs. A flubbed shot with ANY cartridge has a high potential for unrecovered game.

Originally Posted By DPeacher:

Originally Posted By DrDeath:
What about - FEDERAL 223 REM 60GR NOSLER PARTITION?

The short answer: Those work very well.


The loooooong answer:

I made these posts in several similar threads. Someone should make a compilation of the threads on this subject and tack it...


.416 Rigby with a 400gn Hornady softpoint @ 2500 FPS at the muzzle.Range 150 yards. The bullet entered the left chest just in front ofshoulder (deer quartering towards me) obliterated the top half of theheart and liquified the front half of the lungs, then came to rest onthe ball joint of the right hip. The 10 point buck stayed on his hoovesand ran 40 yards. No blood trail, not a single drop.

.223 Rem with a 60 gn Nosler Partition @ 2900 fps. Range 165 yards.Classic broadside shot just behind the shoulder on a mature doe. Bulletpenetrated completely through the ribcage leaving a golf ball sizedexit. The heart was missing 2/3 of it's top half with 6" diameter areaof both lungs liquified. The doe ran about 50 yards. OK blood trail.

.223 Rem with 62 gn Barnes TSX @ 2900 fps. Range 145 yards. Classicbroadside shot high in the shoulder on a mature doe. Bullet penetratedcompletely breaking both shoulders leaving a quarter sized exit wound.6" diameter area of both lungs liquified. Doe DRT. Not a single step.(I had the exact same shot and performance using a 120 gn Barnes TSXout of my 6.5x57 @ 2900 fps on a small 8 point. My son had the sameperformance with a 180 gn TSX out of the .308 @ 100 yards. There issomething "magic" about the high shoulder shot, 1/2 to 2/3 of the wayup the chest/shoulder that just seems to work like a light switch. Ithink it traumatizes the spine and knocks the deer out, then they bleedout before coming to.)

7mm Rem Mag with 140 gn Nosler Ballistic Tip @ 3000 fps. Range 100yards. Classic broadside shot on a mature buck. Buck dropped at theshot, then while my buddy and his young son were giving each other highfives, the deer walked off into a thorn thicket so dense we had tocrawl into it on our hands an knees. We followed a blood trail that attimes was so heavy it looked like someone was pouring it out by theCoke can. The trail went on for about 400 yards through the thicket,then into an open field where it tapered off to a few drops thenstopped. The deer was never recovered. It's as if it "rubbed some dirton it and walked it off". (The year before, my son shot a nice doe witha .223 62 gn TSX from the exact same blind and had the exact sameresults, except the blood trail only went about 100 yards. The folkswho own that property say they have lost DOZENS of deer the same wayfrom that blind with 7x57, .270, .308... As hard as we all try torecover every animal shot, there will always be a few that haunt us.)

I've seen enough deer shot with the .223 to know that a 60 gn orheavier bullet designed for use on deer sized game will leave a woundchannel that is virtually indistinguishable from that of a .270 or.30-06 IN THE CASE OF BROADSIDE SHOTS WITH RANGES OF 250 YARDS OR LESS.I've seen enough deer shot to know that you can NEVER count on a bloodtrail even when using a .416 Rigby. Heart shots work, but the deer isgoing to run for 30 to 200 yards, maybe more. High shoulder shots tendto be DRT but you are going to waste a large part of both shoulders.There's not a cartridge in existence that doesn't have at least 1"failure" on it's record.

.223 with 60 gn and heavier bullets will work just fine if the hunteris patient enough to wait for a shot that will pass through both lungs.A flubbed shot with ANY cartridge has a high potential for unrecoveredgame.


I know there is a bit (quite possibly a LOT) of disbelief/hesitationfor a lot of folks to trust a .223 to properly do the job on deer sizedanimals. I WAS ONE OF THOSE PEOPLE. I grew up when most of theexperienced hunters viewed .243 and 6mm Rem as marginal, and PROPERdeer cartridges started with the .257 Roberts.

Given the projectiles available in most areas in the 70's and 80's, oldcup and core designs the best of the era being the Remington Core Locktand the Hornady Interlock, the seasoned hunters were probably right.Sure, the Nosler Partition had been available to handloaders for about40 years, but just as today the VAST majority of hunters bought theirammo from the local sporting goods counter at Walmart or a local Mom& Pop gun shop, and they probably decided to buy whichever box wascheapest. The major manufactures didn't really start offering their'premium' bullets until the late 80's early 90's, and if the local shopeven carried them, they were usually twice the price of the standardoffering (that really hasn't changed over the years). Remember, thiswas WAY before the internet and the Cabela's and Bass Pro mega marts.

Back then, the manufactures marketed ammo and rifles tailored tospecific niches. They loaded .223, .22-250, .243/6mm ammo with lightweight thin jacketed bullets, and they offered rifles in those caliberswith slow twist 1/12 or 1/14 barrels. Using those combinations on deersized game most certainly was a BAD idea. Remember when a 55 gn .224"was HEAVY? What about 80 gn .243"... They didn't offer anything elsebecause their slow twist factory barrels couldn't stabilize anythingheavier.

Technology has made BIG advances over the last 30 years. Electronicsand data communications have been the leaders of the pack, but thebullet tinkerers have been busy too. The current bullet technology isFAR ahead of the old cup and core designs. Bonded core bullets like theSwift Scirocco, Hornady Interbond, Nosler Accubond, Remington CoreLockt Ultra Bond are marvelous. The monolithic copper bullets like theBarnes TSX and the Hornady GMX are astoundingly effective.

We can thank the custom barrel makers for the fast twist barrels wehave today and the custom bullet makers for the heavier, bondedcore/monolithic copper bullets that are available. Today's .223 Remloaded with a 70 gn Barnes TSX coupled with a 1/7 twist barrel isVASTLY different than the .223 rifle and ammo on the shelves in 1980.

The very first deer I saw taken with a .223 was shot by the now ex-wifeof a well known member here. She wanted to hunt, but the .270 herhusband was using kicked too much for her to handle. I had been readingof many folks using .223 loaded with quality 60 gn and heavier bulletsfor a few years, and I decided to load up some 60 gn Nosler Partitionswith an eye on shooting a deer with them. Well, as things worked out,Nicole was the one who actually got to do it. We spent about an hour onthe 100 yard practice range making sure she could keep every shot in a4" circle, and we talked all about whitetail anatomy and bulletplacement. Nicole went out to the stand that afternoon and shot a smalldoe at 40 yards. The deer was quartering away from her. The bulletentered on the left side about 3 ribs up from the diaphragm, itobliterated the liver and both lungs, then broke the right shoulderleaving a golf ball sized exit wound. She said the deer dropped in itstracks and kicked for a few seconds, but died before she could reload.That deer was hanging in the skinning shed next to another one that hadbeen dropped with a .270 when I got back to the ranch house (emptyhanded, I should add). The wound channels were VERY similar. She wasquite happy with herself and she had every right to be. She went out tothat stand alone and cleanly killed her first deer without ANYassistance.

In all honesty, the .223 worked a LOT better than I ever thought itwould. Over the years the range has increased but the results haveremained consistent. I'm comfortable that a properly loaded .223 isvery capable of cleanly killing 250 lb whitetails out to 250 yards ASLONG AS THE HUNTER HAS THE PATIENCE TO WAIT FOR A REASONABLE BROADSIDESHOT AND THE SKILL TO PUT THE BULLET THROUGH BOTH LUNGS.


Bostekrisco
Member
Offline
Posts: 217
Feedback: 100% (14)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/21/2009 4:33:12 PM
I'm going to try my 16" 1x9 for the first time this year.

I bought a bag of Winny 64 gr Powerpoints and settled on 25 gr RL15, Remington 7.5s and 2.25"

I'll be using a Bushnell Holosite and maybe a 3X magnifier.
eudyta63
Offline
Posts: 247
Feedback: 0% (0)
Link To This Post
Posted: 10/21/2009 6:06:02 PM
I think that I'll try my AR 15 as well this year.I am going to go with the 62 grain Barnes triple shock bullet.
Page:  / 17