I use the gators rear round on my 6' Kubota deck. I like them better than the stocks and they last longer. Usually 2-3 seasons but by then they are shot and wore down to a nub. I've had varied success with a mulching plug, but then we have a ton of oak leaves and I mow about 4 acres. I made my plug out of expanded steel to let some airflow through and it works well if things are bone dry, no grass cutting, just leaves be mulched. With the plug and dry leaves it will churn leaves into powder. Lately I've been breaking the patches up into swaths about 75' wide. I mow Nascar style without the plug and blow onto the uncut section and keep piling them up. Then a couple passes to disperse the clipping at the end blowing out. After a day or so the wind blows things around and you can't see where the swaths were and things look pretty even.