User Panel
Posted: 8/25/2015 9:45:53 AM EDT
aluminum, stainless steel and titanium... soo many to choose from. i would say that SS is the best way to go.. but there are several different options depending on the adventure.. so, whats the best option for your pack.. "camping/bushing it" using open flame and grill grate and such? i'm looking for a good set to pack in my kit for a good price.. i don't mind paying a little extra for good quality and something that will last.
|
|
[#1]
Alum is light, but sucks to cook with and is weak. Stainless cooks great, strong...but is heavy as hell. Titanium is light, strong, and decent to cook with..sans a skillet(easy to burn). I'm a ti guy. Been using the same ti pot for 20yrs.
|
|
[#2]
Quoted:
Alum is light, but sucks to cook with and is weak. Stainless cooks great, strong...but is heavy as hell. Titanium is light, strong, and decent to cook with..sans a skillet(easy to burn). I'm a ti guy. Been using the same ti pot for 20yrs. View Quote by ti.. i assume titanium.. just want to make sure.. so i've read that it is easily warpped.. obviously you haven't had that problem if you've been using the same pot for 20yrs.. do you cook in open flame or on grate or hang it..etc..etc. i've used aluminum before..been a long time ago.. when i was a young buck.. but i'm packing out a set up to take my oldest boy into the woods.. he's 10 and it's time.. we get out into the woods a lot.. but its time to get out and get nasty...lol.. so.. i'm looking for the best options and solutions for gear. i do but don't necessarily have a budget..but i want to be smart about what i buy and get the best bang for my buck! god i can't believe i'm just not getting around to this with him! not sure who is excited more.. LOL |
|
[#3]
I use copper bottomed stainless mess kit. They're like $20.
Why? Its not because they're cheap. Heat dissipation is real important when cooking over a fire. Over a stove, its all bitching about how it sticks or not. During the early survival camps, we use to have a running joke going on Titanium sporks. These guys would show up carrying 5lb hatchets and crank radios the size of a boom box, but they'd have this spork they'd keep track of like it was the only Kbar on a deserted island. Titainium has its place, shaving ounces, but shaving ounces while ignoring pounds. well don't be that guy. Aluminum works and its light weight, just know its going to oxide, stain, and dent over time. Many a year I've used that cheap crap so I can't complain. Tj |
|
[#4]
Cast Iron for the win.
The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. |
|
[#6]
Quoted:
Cast Iron for the win. The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. View Quote do you pack that in your gear and haul it or do "truck camp" as i call it.. you know. pile all you gear in the truck..pull up to a camp site and just drag out what you need when you need it.. that type of thing? cast iron is heavy man.. even the small skillets i have.. i'm not sure that i would pack them. but truck camping.. cast iron for the win.. |
|
[#7]
Quoted:
No open fires. Always a backpacking stove. Lots of snow melting. Theres a learning curve regarding that. First time, I let the melting snow recede off the bottom, and it turned blue there and warped a little. That was about 18yrs ago, and about 500 trips since(I kept a log), a lot of which was winter/snow camping. Still going strong otherwise. Its a 1.3ltr Snowpeak. Great do-all size. Recently. I've taken to using this 3 piece ti Snowpeak set(wouldn't have, but I inherited it new and unused, from my late brother 2yrs ago). Nests together, with the fuel canister and stove wind guard included, all going inside of it. Like this in its mesh stuff sack, in the bottom of this pic... <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20017_zpsktcwu1bb.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20017_zpsktcwu1bb.jpg</a> Here it is opened up, with the stove wind guard installed(note stove w/o it in top pic). The skillet acts as pot lid when not in use. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20050_zpsmcaqfxjm.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20050_zpsmcaqfxjm.jpg</a> I've also had this ti MSR spoon for about 18-19yrs. I don't use sporks. Its still going strong too. The white heavy duty plastic backpacking spoons WILL break after a yr or two of heavy use. Been there done that a couple times. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower017/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20135_zpsxy9mj7cv.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower017/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20135_zpsxy9mj7cv.jpg</a> View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Alum is light, but sucks to cook with and is weak. Stainless cooks great, strong...but is heavy as hell. Titanium is light, strong, and decent to cook with..sans a skillet(easy to burn). I'm a ti guy. Been using the same ti pot for 20yrs. by ti.. i assume titanium.. just want to make sure.. so i've read that it is easily warpped.. obviously you haven't had that problem if you've been using the same pot for 20yrs.. do you cook in open flame or on grate or hang it..etc..etc. i've used aluminum before..been a long time ago.. when i was a young buck.. but i'm packing out a set up to take my oldest boy into the woods.. he's 10 and it's time.. we get out into the woods a lot.. but its time to get out and get nasty...lol.. so.. i'm looking for the best options and solutions for gear. i do but don't necessarily have a budget..but i want to be smart about what i buy and get the best bang for my buck! god i can't believe i'm just not getting around to this with him! not sure who is excited more.. LOL No open fires. Always a backpacking stove. Lots of snow melting. Theres a learning curve regarding that. First time, I let the melting snow recede off the bottom, and it turned blue there and warped a little. That was about 18yrs ago, and about 500 trips since(I kept a log), a lot of which was winter/snow camping. Still going strong otherwise. Its a 1.3ltr Snowpeak. Great do-all size. Recently. I've taken to using this 3 piece ti Snowpeak set(wouldn't have, but I inherited it new and unused, from my late brother 2yrs ago). Nests together, with the fuel canister and stove wind guard included, all going inside of it. Like this in its mesh stuff sack, in the bottom of this pic... <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20017_zpsktcwu1bb.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20017_zpsktcwu1bb.jpg</a> Here it is opened up, with the stove wind guard installed(note stove w/o it in top pic). The skillet acts as pot lid when not in use. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20050_zpsmcaqfxjm.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower020/Shining%20Rock%20solo%205%208%20014%20050_zpsmcaqfxjm.jpg</a> I've also had this ti MSR spoon for about 18-19yrs. I don't use sporks. Its still going strong too. The white heavy duty plastic backpacking spoons WILL break after a yr or two of heavy use. Been there done that a couple times. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower017/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20135_zpsxy9mj7cv.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower017/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20135_zpsxy9mj7cv.jpg</a> gotcha! no snow here.. if it did.. the world would end!! LOL.. but.. in the current config i'm building i do have a small "smoker grate" that will fit perfectly in my pack, so that would make using titanium no issue. |
|
[#8]
I really like stainless steel. I'm not a big fan of aluminum. The titanium is neat but I don't own any so can't speak from experience.
|
|
[#9]
Quoted:
do you pack that in your gear and haul it or do "truck camp" as i call it.. you know. pile all you gear in the truck..pull up to a camp site and just drag out what you need when you need it.. that type of thing? cast iron is heavy man.. even the small skillets i have.. i'm not sure that i would pack them. but truck camping.. cast iron for the win.. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Cast Iron for the win. The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. do you pack that in your gear and haul it or do "truck camp" as i call it.. you know. pile all you gear in the truck..pull up to a camp site and just drag out what you need when you need it.. that type of thing? cast iron is heavy man.. even the small skillets i have.. i'm not sure that i would pack them. but truck camping.. cast iron for the win.. I'm guilty, I pack what I think I want for the week Into a wood crate and take off. but my crate doubles as a table. Yes I'm a truck camper. |
|
[#10]
Cookware is most often heavy.
Boilwaterware can be very light. I prefer SS if I am really going to cook, but Al or Ti if I am carrying it all very far. Cast iron for hunting camp. All about trade offs. Heavier, thicker pots and pans as a rule cook better and more even than thinner ones. Likewise, copper, copper clad stainless and cast iron as the metals distribute heat more evenly and cook better than say Al or even Ti in my experience. Everyone's idea and style of 'cooking' in the back county is different. You just gotta find what works for your style. |
|
[#11]
I just boil water, so I have a Ti pot. If we truck camp the night before at the trail head, I have a grill grate to cook my steak on. |
|
[#12]
Quoted:
I'm guilty, I pack what I think I want for the week Into a wood crate and take off. but my crate doubles as a table. Yes I'm a truck camper. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Cast Iron for the win. The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. do you pack that in your gear and haul it or do "truck camp" as i call it.. you know. pile all you gear in the truck..pull up to a camp site and just drag out what you need when you need it.. that type of thing? cast iron is heavy man.. even the small skillets i have.. i'm not sure that i would pack them. but truck camping.. cast iron for the win.. I'm guilty, I pack what I think I want for the week Into a wood crate and take off. but my crate doubles as a table. Yes I'm a truck camper. hey..no worries brother... truck camped for years.. and will continue to do so.. not really planning on a long trek or hike style camping adventure anytime soon.. this is just me and the boy.. but i do want something packable. |
|
[#13]
Quoted:
Cookware is most often heavy.Boilwaterware can be very light. I prefer SS if I am really going to cook, but Al or Ti if I am carrying it all very far. Cast iron for hunting camp. All about trade offs. Heavier, thicker pots and pans as a rule cook better and more even than thinner ones. Likewise, copper, copper clad stainless and cast iron as the metals distribute heat more evenly and cook better than say Al or even Ti in my experience. Everyone's idea and style of 'cooking' in the back county is different. You just gotta find what works for your style. this!! very very true.. but i still like to hear what others think, like, use.. many options are always good or bad.. i just like them...LOL!! View Quote |
|
[#14]
Quoted:
hey..no worries brother... truck camped for years.. and will continue to do so.. not really planning on a long trek or hike style camping adventure anytime soon.. this is just me and the boy.. but i do want something packable. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Cast Iron for the win. The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. do you pack that in your gear and haul it or do "truck camp" as i call it.. you know. pile all you gear in the truck..pull up to a camp site and just drag out what you need when you need it.. that type of thing? cast iron is heavy man.. even the small skillets i have.. i'm not sure that i would pack them. but truck camping.. cast iron for the win.. I'm guilty, I pack what I think I want for the week Into a wood crate and take off. but my crate doubles as a table. Yes I'm a truck camper. hey..no worries brother... truck camped for years.. and will continue to do so.. not really planning on a long trek or hike style camping adventure anytime soon.. this is just me and the boy.. but i do want something packable. It's all good, I've taken my daughter for years camping. She has her own cast iron pan she likes cooking in. |
|
[#16]
Quoted:
Heres the kit in the above pics. $50. http://www.sportsmanswarehouse.com/sportsmans/Snow-Peak-3-Piece-TI/productDetail/Mess-Kits/prod9999012244/cat101732 As I've posted here recently, the hard foam mil spec green sleeping pad material, is the best for what we call a Duck pad. One of my "must go" items. Endless uses... Cooking platform for the stove(especially in an tent)..set a hot pot on, on ones lap(like in the above pic in my previous post)), tent floor, etc....for a seat along the trail or camp...also a great seat when pumping water along a creek with otherwise wet soft moss on its banks...fan a fire with it...place it at the door of ones tent so ones knees can go on it(when going in/out), sparing the tent floor regarding long term abrasion...cutting board...stand on while changing pants/boots/socks/whatever along the wet trail...goes under ones feet when in the camp chair while not wearing ones boots....etc etc. I carry on ein my day pack as well. And it weighs less about 1oz. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/hipower90hipower018/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20082_zpsrdzydwlq.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower018/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20082_zpsrdzydwlq.jpg</a> Being used when sitting in snow, or even this wet bridge(all 4 of us are sitting on one at this moment), etc. Lean against the pack while sitting on it. Presto. Works awesome. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/InianPeaks128.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/InianPeaks128.jpg</a> Or setting along this creek while filtering ones water. Show me a dry place to sit otherwise... At least if ones not wearing shell pants. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/InianPeaks003.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/InianPeaks003.jpg</a> Or a stove platform in this kind of environment. Beats starting a grass fire lol. Note 16oz sleeping bag. Western Mtneering Highlite. Stuffs to the size of a grapefruit. Good to the mid to low 20s(conservatively rated to 35*). About $350. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/WayneMorrisWorlds0913202_zpsf3e0384a.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/WayneMorrisWorlds0913202_zpsf3e0384a.jpg</a> This whole load with food(3 days) is about 15-16lbs total(less water. usually carry about 1-1.5 liter at any given time. water is no problem in this region). Tons of room...decadent chair(used with the sleeping pad)....4 season shelter...filter..stove...etc. I'm not going without. <a href="http://s35.photobucket.com/user/hipower90hipower/media/WayneMorrisWorlds0913232_zps88bbdaa4.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/WayneMorrisWorlds0913232_zps88bbdaa4.jpg</a> View Quote nice man!! all kinds of terrain.. what boot are you running? |
|
[#17]
Quoted: Heres the kit in the above pics. $50. http://www.sportsmanswarehouse.com/sportsmans/Snow-Peak-3-Piece-TI/productDetail/Mess-Kits/prod9999012244/cat101732 As I've posted here recently, the hard foam mil spec green sleeping pad material, is the best for what we call a Duck pad. One of my "must go" items. Endless uses... Cooking platform for the stove(especially in an tent)..set a hot pot on, on ones lap(like in the above pic in my previous post)), tent floor, etc....for a seat along the trail or camp...also a great seat when pumping water along a creek with otherwise wet soft moss on its banks...fan a fire with it...place it at the door of ones tent so ones knees can go on it(when going in/out), sparing the tent floor regarding long term abrasion...cutting board...stand on while changing pants/boots/socks/whatever along the wet trail...goes under ones feet when in the camp chair while not wearing ones boots....etc etc. I carry on ein my day pack as well. And it weighs less about 1oz. http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/hipower90hipower018/Middleprong%20Wilderness%2011%2013%20082_zpsrdzydwlq.jpg Being used when sitting in snow, or even this wet bridge(all 4 of us are sitting on one at this moment), etc. Lean against the pack while sitting on it. Presto. Works awesome. http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/InianPeaks128.jpg Or setting along this creek while filtering ones water. Show me a dry place to sit otherwise... At least if ones not wearing shell pants. http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/InianPeaks003.jpg Or a stove platform in this kind of environment. Beats starting a grass fire lol. Note 16oz sleeping bag. Western Mtneering Highlite. Stuffs to the size of a grapefruit. Good to the mid to low 20s(conservatively rated to 35*). About $350. http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/WayneMorrisWorlds0913202_zpsf3e0384a.jpg This whole load with food(3 days) is about 15-16lbs total(less water. usually carry about 1-1.5 liter at any given time. water is no problem in this region). Tons of room...decadent chair(used with the sleeping pad)....4 season shelter...filter..stove...etc. I'm not going without. http://i35.photobucket.com/albums/d161/hipower90hipower/WayneMorrisWorlds0913232_zps88bbdaa4.jpg View Quote |
|
[#18]
Quoted:
Cast Iron for the win. The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. View Quote Can't argue with that. If it was light enough for me to carry, I'd be right there. Stuff you can haul in a truck, I'm pretty fond of old school enamel ware too. Absolutely nothing better than a pot of fresh coffee, beans crushed that morning, cooked in an old school enamel percolator. UMMM, umm, good. Not even to mention plates that can actually hold something, you can cut a piece of meat, and not have to worry about it all dumping on the ground. You know I love the simplicity of my pack stuff but man are we missing out on some damn fine eating. Tj |
|
[#20]
Not necessary or we'd all have copper pots. You want enough conductivity for it to heat evenly but not so much it dissipates unevenly. That's why cast iron is still so popular. Even though you have an uneven fire, it cooks even because it retains its heat.
When it comes to you guys heating water like Waldo posted, heck, you can't beat Titanium. Its not like boiling water is going to be impacted by uneven burn. You want to know how your kit works, fry some bacon over an open fire. |
|
[#21]
Quoted:
Can't argue with that. If it was light enough for me to carry, I'd be right there. Stuff you can haul in a truck, I'm pretty fond of old school enamel ware too. Absolutely nothing better than a pot of fresh coffee, beans crushed that morning, cooked in an old school enamel percolator. UMMM, umm, good. Not even to mention plates that can actually hold something, you can cut a piece of meat, and not have to worry about it all dumping on the ground. You know I love the simplicity of my pack stuff but man are we missing out on some damn fine eating. Tj View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Cast Iron for the win. The only other is a stainless steel pot for spaghetti. Can't argue with that. If it was light enough for me to carry, I'd be right there. Stuff you can haul in a truck, I'm pretty fond of old school enamel ware too. Absolutely nothing better than a pot of fresh coffee, beans crushed that morning, cooked in an old school enamel percolator. UMMM, umm, good. Not even to mention plates that can actually hold something, you can cut a piece of meat, and not have to worry about it all dumping on the ground. You know I love the simplicity of my pack stuff but man are we missing out on some damn fine eating. Tj Right on all points. Ummm Morning dew coffee, nothing better. |
|
[#22]
|
|
[#23]
View Quote Man, that's nice and a good price too, but couldn't help noticing it weighs 2 oz more than the copper bottom mess kit I carry now. |
|
[#24]
|
|
[#25]
TJ -
I got confused about the weight too... If you scroll down 6.2 oz (not 1#). My Hard Ano set is just under 1#: 3L pot and Lid 2L pot and Lid MSR Pot Grabber Nylon Carry Bag My normal group is 3, plenty of room for soup and main course -> 5.3 oz each. Ditch the 2L pot and it is lighter yet. |
|
[#27]
picked one of these lil guys up yesterday
http://i5.walmartimages.com/dfw/dce07b8c-b99c/k2-_19200b17-63d7-4ffc-b9ca-b3193ef4ca55.v1.jpg |
|
[#29]
I like TJ's enamel ware. We burned something into the bottom of it at the last big camp it and it went to his house to be cleaned cause we forgot to let it soak overnight to clean it up.
I tend to dent and chip up enamel ware, I am a clutz at times, so I skip enamel ware. I never got into ti because if I need to lose weight from what is going hiking I just need to lose it from my biere gut. I love stainless steel. I do have cast iron in the house kitchen but lots of stainless steel in the kitchen as well. I grew up with aluminum mess kits in the boy scouts and don't like aluminum for cooking. I love aluminum for other stuff, but not cook wear. Between stainless steel coffee cups and stainless steel mixing bowls and measuring cups I can put together a small kit that does not match but I can get by with stuff not matching. I like small stoves like esbit or canteen stoves that are easy for what I want to do. I tend to use a mixing bowl rather than a pie plate like someone put in a pic above, the mixing bowl will have a flat bottom but depending on what you want to do the pie plate might do better. I do have some of the home made alcohol or wood stick burning stoves as well. |
|
[#30]
Solo Stove makes some killer stainless cookware that isn't super heavy. Only AL stuff I have is a Coleman set that fits my svea123 perfectly.
And I'm that guy with the ti spork, even when car camping. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.