At different times I've had a current issue style folding e tool, an old school WW2 shovel (that I should have kept), and my current iteration is a D handled pointed shovel. I have used it in snow. I would much rather have the D handled pointed shovel than a flimsy snow shovel. Case in point, I pulled over to the side of a logging road to let someone pass. I had pulled onto a flat of ice crusted snow that looked like road shoulder but the actual ground was lower than what the snowplow blade left, Of course I broke through and was stuck. The larger D handled shovel had the strength to bust through the crust to make a path on real earth to get out. Otherwise the crust was strong enough to hold each spinning wheel in it's own pocket. A plastic shovel would not have done the job and would have likely broke. An e tool would have but the extra 2 feet of handle make a job that much easier. Mine shovel sits behind my rear seat backs. All I have to do is open the rear door and snake the shovel out, I don't even have to tip the seat back.