Quote History Quoted:
ChrisGarrett
Why do you like the Maha over the Lacrosse?
Lacrosse BC1000 owner here and just wondering what I am missing by not having a Maha.
View Quote
I like the LaCrosse and I actually travel with it in my suitcase, since it's substantially smaller vs. the Maha, but there in lies the problem.
That smaller case has a couple of problems--one, getting smaller AAA sized batteries in and out, especially if you're a big guy with big fingers, can be a problem. I have girly hands and sometimes putting them in and pulling them out is a chore.
Secondly, that smaller case traps heat. Your 1000 has a max charge rate of 1A and my 700 has a max charge rate of 700mA, but in that cramped charger, those batteries can heat up and trip the thermal protection, shutting the charger down, until things cool back down. No fatal flaw, but it does add time and my BC700 has done this often enough.
If you've got older batteries, things can trip more frequently, but it's just a 'physics' issue to me and this plagues the AccuPower IQ 328, as well, which is almost identical to the LaCrosse offerings. The Maha just has a lot more space around the batteries and cooling vents to whisk away that heat and keep things relatively cool.
Don't get me wrong, the LaCrosse/AP chargers are quite capable, but NiMH batteries like to terminate via heat and voltage and you just can't throw a fan on them to cool things down, because you're likely to cause the charger to miss termination and over-charge those batteries.
I've had a couple of missed terminations with my LC charger and never with the Maha.
The Maha is just a bit more sophisticated and has a more extensive suite of features, but it's not perfect. It's back-lit display cannot be turned off and that's a problem for some of us. Plus, some feel that at 1.47v, the Maha tends to undercharge NiMH batteries as a rule, so some of us would like to see something around 1.50v-1.51v, similar to where the LaCrosse chargers terminate charge.
Chris