Quote History Quoted:
What would be a good alternative?
View Quote
What's your need? How much server weather camping do you do? A few observations. First, Mountain Hardware does make good gear, so it's nice to see them collaborating and making this for the military, even if on a small scale. Second, I haven't found out what the material is, but it's obviously designed as a single wall tent. These are best used with good ventilation as they will generate condensation...very cold, dry climates are their target environment. I'm disappointed the smaller "observation" opening doesn't have mesh...it would create excellent air flow with the larger opening...of course, that's a typical 3-season necessity when you're fighting both condensation and the flying insect invasion. The weight sucks, but that's typical of the construction designed for Neanderthal use and of course, true 4-season, severe weather use. Still, that's pretty heavy for a single-wall tent. The awning, is a addition. As a converted hammock camper, I've spent many field exercises in tents and there's nothing worse than crawling out of your tent (or into your tent) with mud and shit right outside your door. Even an improvised door mat doesn't work all that well and on more than one occasion I've rigged up a poncho to cover the entrance.
For the group buy price, it's competitive with many similar, mid-level four-season tents. The MSRP is more in line with the high-end cuben-fiber tents...those can be quite spendy and require more care; of course their advantage is they weight half of what this tent weighs.
I like the design, but just can't warm up to the weight. Yes, it's a four-season tent and yes, it has some nice features for a drab-color tent, but that's a lot of weight for 1-person shelter. Most of the expensive 4-season tents are about that same weight but designed for two people. It is what it is and a 4.5 pound one-man tent isn't outrageous, just expensive when considering a backpacking tent if that is your purpose.
ROCK6