AR15.Com Archives
 Marlin 1894 .44 Mag
gunnut284  [Team Member]
11/29/2011 6:43:49 PM
I just bought a Marlin 1894 .44 Mag and have a few questions? It was somewhat of an impulse buy as the price was too good to pass up ($300).

The first two digits of the serial number are "27", if I read right elsewhere it was made in 1973. Am I reading this right? It doesn't have a crossbolt safety.

It has a Micro-Groove barrel, is it fine to shoot lead bullets? I have a bunch of .44 Mag and Special brass and a bunch of cast bullets which was part of the appeal.

Last, what are these going for these days? The metal/bluing is in good shape and the wood has a few nicks. Probably a 90-95% gun. I was thinking of modifying it but want to make sure its not something special before I do modification.

Sorry for the lack of pictures, I'll try to get some later.

Here are some pictures with big brother Guide Gun:


reelserious  [Team Member]
11/29/2011 7:01:28 PM
it is fine to use cast lead. Just as a tip, use the largest ones you can get .431 if possible .430 at a minimum, trust me on this.


http://www.midwayusa.com/product/150058/oregon-trail-laser-cast-bullets-44-caliber-431-diameter-240-grain-lead-semi-wadcutter-box-of-500




HardShell  [Life Member]
11/29/2011 8:28:23 PM
Great find at that price –– I woulda.
ClemY  [Member]
11/29/2011 8:33:39 PM
Lead will often shoot well in the Microgroove barrel, use large bullets and don't load it too hot.
OlCrow  [Team Member]
11/29/2011 10:50:42 PM
Octagon or round barrel?

The value will differ if it has an octagon barrel or a round one.

1894 Octagon 44 Mag, only made in 1973, one of 2,957
Someone before me added the recoil pad.


gunnut284  [Team Member]
11/29/2011 11:07:56 PM
Round barrel, that octagonal is great looking. I looked at a Canadian Centenial Win 94 earlier in the day that appealed to me due to its octagonal barrel. Didn't buy that one though.
akuser-47  [Member]
11/30/2011 12:14:30 AM
Great find god I have been on the hunt for a 336 or 1894 in .357 or .44 mag and had no luck getting a deal yet sucks glad for you great find.
SickMAK90  [Team Member]
12/1/2011 10:09:17 AM
I found one very similar to the way you found for ~$350, and I am very tempted to pick it up. I know the Marlins had a "oversized" barrel, and I was wondering if it really affects anything if I shoot factory loads.
gunnut284  [Team Member]
12/4/2011 8:20:02 PM
Added a couple pictures with the 1895 Guide Gun I picked up a few weeks ago. It just a partial family picture because my 1895 LTD-IV .45-70 and rough 39M are not in there.
StagArmslower  [Team Member]
12/10/2011 5:58:07 PM
I have one with crossbolt safety. It was doing Marlin jam all the time(got it new). I fixed it myself by welding the cam and reshaping it. Now feeds anything and is very accurate. I have to clean it after shooting about 40 rounds(at least brush it few times)
50cal  [Team Member]
12/10/2011 11:17:04 PM
I have one also that I picked for a steal at $100 some years ago. Lots of bluing gone. Parkerized it then black powdercoated it. It has been a great little rifle. It has a MicroGroove barrel too. Shoots cast leads extremely well.
ScottyPotty  [Team Member]
12/20/2011 1:04:44 PM
I just picked one of these up, I figured it would be a good animal dispatching round without the sound of a rifle going off. I'm currently working on sub sonic loads.
RIPRonReagan  [Member]
12/20/2011 7:50:02 PM
I shoot my 1894 all the time with big (.432") cast bullets. It likes the 200 gr Lee RNFP, 265 grain Ranch Dog, and 310 Lee WNFP all equally.

I use Unique for the light bullets, and H110 for the heavies.

It's easily one of my favorite rifles. I think I got mine for $175 but that was a LONG time ago.
Warhawk  [Team Member]
12/21/2011 4:35:56 PM
Originally Posted By OlCrow:
Octagon or round barrel?

The value will differ if it has an octagon barrel or a round one.

1894 Octagon 44 Mag, only made in 1973, one of 2,957
Someone before me added the recoil pad.
http://4-riders.com/pics/Marlin99/1894Octagon44003.jpg



I recently picked up a 39M octagon, basically the .22LR version of your .44. Also made in '73. These originally had a curved hard rubber buttplate, I would imagine that it wasn't the hot setup on a .44 Mag.





gunnut284  [Team Member]
12/21/2011 4:50:42 PM
Originally Posted By Warhawk:
Originally Posted By OlCrow:
Octagon or round barrel?

The value will differ if it has an octagon barrel or a round one.

1894 Octagon 44 Mag, only made in 1973, one of 2,957
Someone before me added the recoil pad.
http://4-riders.com/pics/Marlin99/1894Octagon44003.jpg



I recently picked up a 39M octagon, basically the .22LR version of your .44. Also made in '73. These originally had a curved hard rubber buttplate, I would imagine that it wasn't the hot setup on a .44 Mag.

http://i.imgur.com/iR6eI.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/vuFhM.jpg



Yeah, I noticed that when I shot it the other day. It wasn't too bad but a softer butt pad/plate would be a bit more comfortable. I may add one at some point.

Very nice 39M BTW, I have a '57 39M round barrel that is in much more rough shape.
Warhawk  [Team Member]
12/21/2011 5:13:48 PM
Originally Posted By gunnut284:
Originally Posted By Warhawk:
Originally Posted By OlCrow:
Octagon or round barrel?

The value will differ if it has an octagon barrel or a round one.

1894 Octagon 44 Mag, only made in 1973, one of 2,957
Someone before me added the recoil pad.
http://4-riders.com/pics/Marlin99/1894Octagon44003.jpg



I recently picked up a 39M octagon, basically the .22LR version of your .44. Also made in '73. These originally had a curved hard rubber buttplate, I would imagine that it wasn't the hot setup on a .44 Mag.

http://i.imgur.com/iR6eI.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/vuFhM.jpg



Yeah, I noticed that when I shot it the other day. It wasn't too bad but a softer butt pad/plate would be a bit more comfortable. I may add one at some point.

Very nice 39M BTW, I have a '57 39M round barrel that is in much more rough shape.


Hard to tell from the pics I posted, but the buttplate on these '73 octagons is curved some, where your 1894 is flat (the cut on the wood). Marlin made the 336 (30-30), 1894, and 39M with octagon barrels in 1973, only that one year. The 1895's made in '74, '75 to ??? also had this curved buttplate. I also have a 1975 model 1895, but it's had a recoil pad on it since before I got it about 20 years ago.
Hanzerik  [Team Member]
12/23/2011 10:33:29 AM
Originally Posted By RIPRonReagan:
I shoot my 1894 all the time with big (.432") cast bullets. It likes the 200 gr Lee RNFP, 265 grain Ranch Dog, and 310 Lee WNFP all equally.

I use Unique for the light bullets, and H110 for the heavies.

It's easily one of my favorite rifles. I think I got mine for $175 but that was a LONG time ago.


Great bullet, specially designed for the Marlin rifles. I shoot them sized to .432 in my .44s (Rossi Lever + Ruger SBH)
Good all around powder for light to mid range loads. I use the RD 265s unchecked when loading as plinking loads with Unique, and slap a gas-check on when loading with 2400.
AeroE  [Moderator]
12/28/2011 10:24:20 PM
Nice gun, I wish I could find an old one in that condition.

1badf350  [Member]
12/29/2011 8:44:36 AM
Nice score! I picked up a brand new in the box 1895MR .450 Marlin for $225 at a gun auction in 2008. If I had known its rarity at the time I wouldnt have thrown the box away.