AR15.Com Archives
 TOPS knives?
ACPjunkie  [Team Member]
1/28/2012 11:42:23 AM
Anybody have any opinion on them? Quality durability? stuff like that
BuffLuver  [Team Member]
1/28/2012 2:09:16 PM
I have the Tom Brown Tracker, beast of a knife.
MikeSearson  [Team Member]
1/28/2012 3:04:31 PM
They are a lot heavier than they look. Quality is there, I'm just mystified as to why they weigh as much as a cinderblock
GoatHerder  [Member]
1/28/2012 8:47:37 PM
...or cost 100 to 150 more than they need to...
bucsfan69  [Member]
1/28/2012 9:18:18 PM
as other people said, they cost maybe a bit more than they should be. with that being said, i have 4 tops knives and like them all. They are built like tanks, hold a good edge and i prefer their sheaths over my esee sheaths. my favorite TOPS i have is the idaho hunter, as it is my field knife when hunting. alot of them are in the "tacticool" category but i like them . If there is a design you like, get it, you wont be dissapointed, they are really great knives.
BCV  [Team Member]
1/28/2012 9:18:39 PM
I have the Tom Brown Scout and I love it. I think the ESEE is the best values, but my tops is unique.
PhoenixRising34  [Member]
1/28/2012 10:50:08 PM
Good stuff because I too have been thinking about grabbing one, nice to read from some that use them.

Thanks for the info guys!
Still_learning  [Member]
1/29/2012 1:03:26 AM
I have their Black Rhino with the micarta scales. It's a very dramatic style. A Beast? Yeah, that's about right.

It weighs what it weighs because it is solid, thick steel from the tip to the pommel and is a fairly large knife. Speaking of pommels, I would not want to get hit with the pommel of the Rhino.

MikeSearson  [Team Member]
1/29/2012 1:07:14 AM
Originally Posted By Still_learning:
I have their Rhino. It's a very dramatic style. A Beast? Yeah, that's about right.

It weighs what it weighs because it is solid, thick steel from the tip to the pommel and is a fairly large knife. Speaking of pommels, I would not want to get hit with the pommel of the Rhino.


Dunno, I swear they fill those things with molten lead. Higher-end knives have spoiled me, I guess.
Still_learning  [Member]
1/29/2012 1:13:02 AM
Originally Posted By MikeSearson:
<snip>.... Higher-end knives have spoiled me, I guess.


That sounds like a bit of snobery and an unwarranted put-down of TOPS owners. Am I misreading you?

I've carried the Black Rhino for a week-long hiking trip and never once felt burdened by it. The sheath is very functional and secure, too. I don't like the aesthetic of Kydex but it is superbely functional. Leather is much more vulnerable to damage.
ACPjunkie  [Team Member]
1/29/2012 9:19:00 AM
Originally Posted By Still_learning:
I have their Black Rhino with the micarta scales. It's a very dramatic style. A Beast? Yeah, that's about right.

It weighs what it weighs because it is solid, thick steel from the tip to the pommel and is a fairly large knife. Speaking of pommels, I would not want to get hit with the pommel of the Rhino.

http://www.topsknives.com/product_thumb.php?img=images/brm101.jpg&w=276&h=207


Thats actually the one I want


MikeSearson  [Team Member]
1/29/2012 11:31:33 AM
Originally Posted By Still_learning:
Originally Posted By MikeSearson:
<snip>.... Higher-end knives have spoiled me, I guess.


That sounds like a bit of snobery and an unwarranted put-down of TOPS owners. Am I misreading you?

I've carried the Black Rhino for a week-long hiking trip and never once felt burdened by it. The sheath is very functional and secure, too. I don't like the aesthetic of Kydex but it is superbely functional. Leather is much more vulnerable to damage.


Yeah sounds like you are. Not putting the owners down at all, i had a lot of their older pieces, and still have 3 ot 4 but their stuff from the past 2 years just feels heavier. than it looks..it looks like it should weigh 13 ounces but weighs 24 ounces and lacks a balance point. The thing is, I don't know why. I have knives made from all the tool steels, carbon steels, stainless...the weight ratio reminds me of a truck spring camp knife I made 15 years ago. Jusrt making an observation, didn't mean to insult you or your choice of cutlery.

I hate kydex as well, but it works on these knives.
MikeSearson  [Team Member]
1/29/2012 5:22:13 PM
Originally Posted By Still_learning:
I have their Black Rhino with the micarta scales. It's a very dramatic style. A Beast? Yeah, that's about right.

It weighs what it weighs because it is solid, thick steel from the tip to the pommel and is a fairly large knife. Speaking of pommels, I would not want to get hit with the pommel of the Rhino.

http://www.topsknives.com/product_thumb.php?img=images/brm101.jpg&w=276&h=207


Good looking knives!